SGTalon
So the Danes were right? Wow 300+ years of technology and we are going back to what was done in the Middle Ages!
PrometheusGoneWild.com
Not sure what they are making the "fabric" out of, but what about maintenance cost? I have a hard time imagining the canvas blades outlasting fiberglass. So they will have to pay someone, with equipment, to go out; stop the turbine and then repair it. The initial cost would be less, but the long term cost may be more....
TechThinker46
Why is golf-ball dimpled? Why jets have winglets? Aerodynamic. Why is windmill blade not *dimpled* or winglet?
socalboomer
or at least 100 years back to when planes were built by stretching fabric over spars. . .
Joel Detrow
@TechThinker46: Dimples are not so much aerodynamic as they simply reduce drag. Windmill blades are in a sense just airplane wings turned at a very sharp angle to the direction of air flow, so I would think dimples would just reduce their efficiency. As for winglets, which take advantage of the wingtip vortex on aircraft wings, (vortices which form from the flow of air down the wing) I believe that because the direction of air flow over windmill blades is a bit different from that over aircraft wings, the vortex isn't the same. Additionally, since a windmill is balanced and the "lift" that the wings produce is not in opposition to gravity, the best way to add more "lift" to the windmill blade is simply to make the blade longer.
Mark A
I still use fabric to cover aircraft wings.
Gadgeteer
Almost exactly 40 years ago, the November 1972 issue of Popular Science had a sailwing wind turbine on its cover. That also used fabric (in that case Dacron) stretched over a rigid framework to form light, strong, inexpensive turbine blades. However, those blades were a lot smaller and didn't have any chordwise ribs.
martinkopplow
Hi Joel.
There are in fact wind turbines with winglets at the tips. (At least here in Germany, where we care for efficiency) but they are not so easy to design: Pointing in the most efficient direction, winglets need to be oriented towards the turbine tower, making a mast-strike more likely, or to avoid this, requiring a longer hub to allow more clearance. Making them point away from the tower (and into the wind) is only the second best solution, efficiency-wise.
Dimples are not per se aerodynamically efficient. There is, however boundary layer tripping on some blades (which is what dimples do), in certain well defined places.
Besides that, fabric covers have deficiencies in surface quality. I wonder how they will come by this, and how they want to control it flexing and making noise on the covered blades.
Tim Collins
I wonder how they will compare for Lightning Protection?
Adrian Akau
It is a good idea. I think that any dimpling should be done to certain portions of car bodies, not to wind turbine blades, to reduce air resistance and to give the car a lower Cd. Someone would have to come up with a machine that would imprint dimples into the metal before it is folded or shaped since once the sheet metal is shaped, it would be difficult to imprint curved surfaces.However, bending the sheet metal with dimples may not be conducive to hydralic benders. A better method might be to cut holes into the metal sheet where the dimples are to be located, bend the sheet meta into the desired shape and then press in prefabricated dimples after the edges of the sheet metal have been treated or painted. Dimples would actually be of different shapes, depending upon the curvature of the metal and might be made of rubber or plastic. The seal would have to be good to avoid water leaks.