Gadgeteer
“I know the bicycle companies hire some pretty sharp engineers, but it seems like they’ve been kind of asleep at the switch for a while,”
They're not as dumb as you think. This is a step back in terms of technology. Ben keeps writing "freehub," which this definitely isn't. It's a removable hub with a freewheel mounted to the frame. Actual freehubs became prevalent in the last three decades because they integrated the hub and freewheel, allowing the hub bearings on the right side to be located all the way at the end of the freewheel. Any mechanical or structual engineer can attest that moving the hub bearings as close as possible to the support points (the frame dropouts) makes the axle less vulnerable to bending. HubDock moves the hub's right bearing back to a point closer to the centerline of the bike, which is just begging for bent axles. It would be possible to get around the weakness by using a larger diameter thru-axle, but the standardized diameter of cassette bodies and their bearings means expanding the axle diameter is not possible.
djmc
Had the same system on my first motorbike back in the early 1980's [1972 Suzuki GT250]. Made life a lot easier.
socalboomer
I"m not so sure, Gadgeteer - I don't see why there is no bearing outboard.
And the bearing on my Shimano gearset is actually at the wheelhub, not out at the gear cluster. . .
JimRD
I like it. But for $379 dollars I'll get my hands dirty.
Martin Hone
Can't recall if the Suzuki GT250 had a similar system as djmc reports, but I know some Pommie bikes had QD or quick detach rear wheels, so nothing new really. Of course, shaft drive and single-sided swing-arm bikes have a similar concept.
Gadgeteer
socalboomer,
How would you transfer forces from a bearing at the end of the freewheel body to this hub? The two parts slide together via a splined interface. They are not structurally fastened together. The only way they can affect each other is to rotate on a common axis. Also, "gearset" and "wheelhub" are not terms used by cyclists or engineers for the component companies, the former because it's not applicable (except in internal gear hubs) and the latter because there is no such word.
MQ
It appears as if there may be 3 bearings in this "effective" axle assembly
The hub will have 2 bearings, and the sprocket mounting assembly will have at least one bearing if not 2.
This is a fairly simple Idea, but it isn't worth the money. (not for $375).
Using a spline to provide positive location of the cassette (freewheel assembly) to the hub, and the threaded axle post tensioned with the Quick release, gives a strong system, the only real difference to a conventional set-up is replacing the sprocket thread with a spline, and cutting the axle in half to be joined with a threaded adapter....
Of course it is still likely to be weaker than a single non-threaded axle, (as the threaded section will be thinner), however the spline with a large contact patch should remove a lot of the bending moment from the axle and transfer it directly to the hub...
Sure, for those who want to put their bike in the car all the time, it may be a godsend, however for those who want to ride rough, and have a strong rear axle, it may not be so-good....
Of course it is really designed for cafe racers, who want to slide the bike in the back of the Audi at the end of a ride, and haven't figured how to remove a wheel without touching the chain... (And have cash to bun)
benonabike
You don't need to touch the drive train components to remove or insert a rear wheel.
If you change the gears so that the chain is on the smallest front chainring and more importantly on the smallest rear cog on the cassette, the chain will have the most slack.
Then when you undo the quick release you can lift the rear wheel off the ground and give it a gentle tap on the top. It should pop free from the frame. With the chain so slack there should be plenty of free movement to extract the wheel without needing to touch the chain or rear dérailleur with your hands.
Reinserting simply requires you line of the smallest cog with the chain slightly in front of the dérailleur, then gently pull it upwards. The rear wheel should pop back into the dropouts quite easily.
I do not get grease or oil on my hands when changing a wheel/tyre on either my road bike or mtb. I get more dirty from the dirt and dust on the tyre itself.
Struggling to see the need for this invention.
Catweazle
Motorcycles have had Quickly Detachable ("QD") hubs that left the chain - and often the brake drum too - in situ when the wheel is removed since the 1950s. I've got one out in my garage right now.
However, in general they are noticeably heavier and cause more friction due to at least one extra bearing than the non-QD component, I would have thought that was a drawback for a pushbike.
Janet Baird Booth
Hey Cycle Studs, it's not about YOU getting grease on YOUR hands!!! This is for the ten million or so riders who aren't nearly as savvy as your- selves. I didn't see much sense in Grip Shifts in '86, I thought Rapid Fire were the best thing going...now SRAM is one of the BIG 3 in the industry!!! Just saying...