mishap October 20, 2015 08:12 AM If it works with wood fibers then wouldn't it be even cheaper to use Hemp? It has so many possible uses and it 'wood' save more trees. I can't wait for Hemp toilet paper! LMAO owlbeyou October 20, 2015 10:30 AM An effective and efficient way to make seawater suitable for our consumption is the challenge of our times. This method shows merit, and we hope for its success further on down the road of development. >The membrane can be used in very remote situations using fire to vaporize the water.Unfortunately, trees aren't very common in the middle east, so we are still left with the obstacle of energy usage. The filtration concept does show promise though. Finding a way to zap the water without using gobs of energy is the key. Raven Bo October 20, 2015 10:43 AM It is silly to say it is LESS energy without actually providing numbers. It cannot be cleaner unless salt and other pollution have some place to be dumped. Also FIRE is not clean as electric pump. piperTom October 20, 2015 11:07 AM So, the brine winds up ON LAND?!? How is that better than mixing it back into the sea? More work needed on this problem. Mac McDougal October 20, 2015 01:04 PM I'm afraid I see desalination as a problem, not a solution. If it were confined to emergency situations, I would support it. But I know humans and technology; if large-scale desalination becomes economically feasible, then one great obstacle to overpopulation--and one great restraint on reckless exploitation of existing fresh water resources--will disappear. And then what? Catweazle October 20, 2015 01:08 PM The Dead Sea is around 1,400 feet below sea level, highly saline and currently suffering from decreasing in volume and area.A hydroelectric system running from the Gulf of Aqaba to the Dead Sea would produce large quantities of energy, much of which could be used for reverse osmosis - a field in which Israel leads the World - so disposal of the salt-enriched brine would not be a problem.Unfortunately, that would require the local Arabs to put aside their enmity of Israel, so that scheme is a non-starter. JohnPilgrim October 20, 2015 01:14 PM I came up with a similar idea about 12 years ago and was laughed at with claims it would never work. Basically I suggested, filtering the sea water and then distilling it, in the same way they make moonshine. And then filter through carbon filters. I presume there would be a slight salty taste, but that could be removed in the same way a water softener removes it... jjgg38 October 20, 2015 02:44 PM As previous comments indicated, this article makes no sense at all without more information.These filters work how long, separating how much salt and other pollutants?What is to be done with the filter material when it is saturated?Can it be cleaned? Is there a recommended method of disposal?Perhaps all the salt should be returned to the ocean? Perhaps the filter material makes some sort of nutrient for ocean farming? Perhaps if washed with ocean water it can be reused?Too many unanswered questions. What is the comparison of CO2 footprint for manufacturing the filter material and its disposal with standard desalination for the same amount of purified water?Without these answers, the article is just a bit of sensationalism, devoid of actual meaning. ezeflyer October 20, 2015 03:00 PM Live aboard sailboats have emergency seawater stills that use sunlight to evaporate pure water from seawater. Pure water condenses on a plastic cover and runs down the sides to be collected. Egypt has plenty of sun. Nik October 20, 2015 03:07 PM Seems promising. Bedouins used to use dried camel poop for cooking fires, so I suppose the same could be used to evaporate water, though it would need an awful lot of it for today's populations. Some prairie grasses can provide large quantities of burnable biomass, and can also feed camels, so, some of the water could be diverted to either one, maybe. Salt residue could possibly be packaged and sold as 'sea-salt,' rich in trace elements.