Biology

Study suggests orca attacks are scaring away great white sharks

Study suggests orca attacks are scaring away great white sharks
Lead scientist Alison Towner inspects the carcass of a great white shark that was killed by an orca
Lead scientist Alison Towner inspects the carcass of a great white shark that was killed by an orca
View 2 Images
Lead scientist Alison Towner inspects the carcass of a great white shark that was killed by an orca
1/2
Lead scientist Alison Towner inspects the carcass of a great white shark that was killed by an orca
The majority of the carcasses were those of subadult great whites – this could put greater pressure on local shark populations, as the animals are being killed before they can breed
2/2
The majority of the carcasses were those of subadult great whites – this could put greater pressure on local shark populations, as the animals are being killed before they can breed

Although great white sharks have few natural enemies, orcas have been known to prey on them. A new study now shows that due to attacks by just two orcas, great whites are staying away from parts of South Africa.

Located about 100 km (62 miles) east of Cape Town, the Gansbaai coast has long been known for its large population of great white sharks.

Since 2017, however, a total of eight dead sharks have washed up on the shore, bearing distinctive bite wounds that were matched to two local male orcas. The orcas, named Port and Starboard, are also readily identifiable by their drooping dorsal fins.

In seven of the shark carcasses, the orcas had eaten the liver and sometimes also the heart. This makes sense, as the liver is a highly nutritious organ. It is believed that the orcas have likely killed many other sharks in order to eat their livers, but the carcasses haven't been spotted by humans, as they didn't wash ashore.

The majority of the carcasses were those of subadult great whites – this could put greater pressure on local shark populations, as the animals are being killed before they can breed
The majority of the carcasses were those of subadult great whites – this could put greater pressure on local shark populations, as the animals are being killed before they can breed

The recently published study, led by scientists from South Africa's Dyer Island Conservation Trust, was conducted over a five-and-a-half-year period. In that time, 14 tagged great white sharks were tracked fleeing areas where the orcas were present. Additionally, great white sightings in those areas have dropped significantly.

"Initially, following an orca attack in Gansbaai, individual great white sharks did not appear for weeks or months," said the lead scientist, Alison Towner. "What we seem to be witnessing though is a large-scale avoidance (rather than a fine-scale) strategy, mirroring what we see used by wild dogs in the Serengeti in Tanzania, in response to increased lion presence. The more the orcas frequent these sites, the longer the great white sharks stay away."

While fewer great whites in the area may make things safer for human swimmers, the decline might not be good news for all species.

"Balance is crucial in marine ecosystems," said Towner. "For example, with no great white sharks restricting Cape fur seal behavior, the seals can predate on critically endangered African penguins, or compete for the small pelagic fish they eat […] To put it simply, although this is a hypothesis for now, there is only so much pressure an ecosystem can take, and the impacts of orcas removing sharks are likely far wider-reaching."

It is thought that Port and Starboard may be members of a relatively rare shark-eating orca subtype, whose behaviour was altered due to a reduction in prey such as other types of sharks.

The research is described in a paper that was recently published in the African Journal of Marine Science.

Source: Taylor & Francis

6 comments
6 comments
Rocky Stefano
I love how scientists try to "tell" us what the proper balance in nature should be for a given ecosystem. Since great whites predate us by 400 million years and Orcas by 50 million perhaps we should let mother nature just do her thing shall we?
MeToo
How are the other sharks getting the message? It's a big ocean.
PAV
Rocky Stefano, yes we really should!
Mel
There was a similar experience outside the Golden Gate in San Francisco a few years ago. Researchers on the Farallon Islands. There was a Great White kill by an Orca. The event was somehow communicated to the areas Great White population and Great White counting done by researches suddenly went to zero.
Claudio
@Mel: maybe one of the GWs left a note floating around... ;-)
LiamKoot
@Rocky Stefano - I don't think there is such a thing as Nature just carrying on with her business anymore. There's a reason why they are now going for the Great Whites and not their more usual diet and hunting in new waters much further North than they normally do. People have messed with Mother Nature and upset the balance, over fishing in the Antarctic, warmer oceans, nothing is normal or as it should be in Mother Nature anymore. These creatures have been around as you say for millions of years, yet Man is making sure they don't see the next 100-1000!