Science

Climate change may have led to 'Mad Max'-style scenes in ancient Andes

The new research doesn't quite predict the climate-based dystopia seen in Hollywood films, but it does conclusively link shifting climate to a pretty serious uptick in head injuries
The new research doesn't quite predict the climate-based dystopia seen in Hollywood films, but it does conclusively link shifting climate to a pretty serious uptick in head injuries

As temperatures climb, so does violence. At least that's the conclusion reached by researchers looking at how ancient cultures in the south central Andes responded to climate change about 1,000 years ago. It may be an important cautionary tale.

Rising sea levels. An expanding troposphere. An increase in the spread of disease-carrying mosquitoes. Even harsher allergy seasons and disrupted sleep patterns. As if we didn't already have enough to worry about from climate change, a new study out of UC Davis says that when the climate shifted between A.D. 470 and 1500, violence among people in the south central Andes increased. If the same patterns hold true today as the world experiences dramatic climate shifts, brutal clashes could unfold a la the 1979 dystopian film "Mad Max."

To reach their conclusion, the UC Davis researchers looked at data from the examination of 2,753 skull fractures from human remains harvested at 58 archaeological sites. They then used the ice record from the Quelccaya glacier found in present day Chile, Peru, and Bolivia to map what was happening in the climate. They found that for every 10-cm decrease in annual ice buildup caused by rising temperatures from what's known as the medieval warm period, the level of violence between people more than doubled. This they concluded by the number of head injuries found in the fossil record, a measure that is frequently employed by archaeologists to study cultural violence.

Interestingly, the uptick in violence – which may have been caused not only by increased temperatures, but by a decrease in precipitation due to shifting weather patterns – was only seen in communities that lived in the Andean highlands. The same trend was not found in communities living in the mid-elevation and coastal areas, which led the researchers to theorize that either drought-like conditions only affected the higher areas or that the communities further down the mountains found peaceful solutions to climate change.

"This disparity likely resulted from variable economic and sociopolitical strategies at different elevations," wrote the researchers. "The failure of rain-fed agriculture during periods of drought and concomitant dissolution of organizing polities likely predisposed highland populations to socioeconomic stress and violent competition for limited resources. Conversely, diversity among lowland and midland economies may have buffered against the effect of drought."

The study has been published in the journal Quaternary Research.

Source: UC Davis

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Flipboard
  • LinkedIn
7 comments
pbethel
During An abnormal moderate climate period conditions allowed surpluses of food that led to population growth.
When the climate returned to normal competition for food and hunger led to violence.
This happened first in the most marginal habitats. In this case higher elevations.
Karmudjun
Machu PIchu has been purported to be an upper echelon planned habitat - like a vacation city for Royalty and Priestly classes. Not a great source of foods or grazing animals. One might hypothesize that the lower level populations with sustainable food supplies were preyed upon by the non-producers during their severe climate swings. We haven't found texts that discuss the population's experience with drought or severe weather changes and they did have a long history of sustenance in South America. But the archeological record is present to inspire our theories!
Nobody
The words "may have" do not fit in a scientific study. It shows too much personal bias in the research. Small sample sizes also fail to prove theory. The scientific method is becoming more political than scientific.
McDesign
This is just more ridiculous speculation. Folks that move from the Northern US aren't noticeably more violent when thy get to Florida.
What about snowbirds - ever heard of a snowbird crime wave? Sheesh.
Unsold
I'll wager they didn't have infrastructure and air conditioning a thousand years ago. Nor a global web of services and communications. Not to deny we'll have problems, but in this millennium we do have tools.
Rumata
The climate between A.D. 950 and 1250 was called "medieval climate optimum" for a good reason, because it was optimal for agriculture, so it was optimal for the whole mankind. It was a "golden age" of Europe (a time when population was growing rapidly), not the age of violence and suffering.

In Europe, the age of violence, wars, starving and epidemic was definitely during the so called Little Ice Age between A.D. 1500-1700, az a result of global COOLING.

So it is totally misleading to draw general conclusions from local violations in Andok during the Medieval Climatic Optimum.

The whole history of mankind proves, that global warming gives us "optimum climate", not violence, starving and suffering.