Environment

Volcano power plan gets U.S. go-ahead

Volcano power plan gets U.S. g...
A plan to tap the thermal energy of the Newberry Volcano is under way (Photo: Joshua Schreiner)
A plan to tap the thermal energy of the Newberry Volcano is under way (Photo: Joshua Schreiner)
View 13 Images
These 17 blue tanks hold over 300,000 gallons of water to supply the stimulation pumps
1/13
These 17 blue tanks hold over 300,000 gallons of water to supply the stimulation pumps
The twin lakes within the Newberry Caldera
2/13
The twin lakes within the Newberry Caldera
Part of the borescope image of well NWG 55-29, showing a large number of fractures on the walls of the wellbore
3/13
Part of the borescope image of well NWG 55-29, showing a large number of fractures on the walls of the wellbore
A borehole seismometer being prepared for insertion into a deep well
4/13
A borehole seismometer being prepared for insertion into a deep well
Photograph of the Newberry EGS demonstration site
5/13
Photograph of the Newberry EGS demonstration site
Preexisting cracks in the deep rock are expanded by hydroshearing. The original, essentially closed crack appears at the left. In the center, the crack is opened by water pressure, whereupon the faces slip a bit along the length of the crack. When the water is removed, the crack faces no longer match, so the crack remains permeable to the flow of water
6/13
Preexisting cracks in the deep rock are expanded by hydroshearing. The original, essentially closed crack appears at the left. In the center, the crack is opened by water pressure, whereupon the faces slip a bit along the length of the crack. When the water is removed, the crack faces no longer match, so the crack remains permeable to the flow of water
The Newberry EGS project will involve three stages of stimulation, or crack network expansion, at different depths to effectively use the power of the hot volcanic rock
7/13
The Newberry EGS project will involve three stages of stimulation, or crack network expansion, at different depths to effectively use the power of the hot volcanic rock
The Newberry EGS demonstration project is located near the boundaries of the Newberry National Volcanic Monument
8/13
The Newberry EGS demonstration project is located near the boundaries of the Newberry National Volcanic Monument
Control room for the Newberry EGS pumping station
9/13
Control room for the Newberry EGS pumping station
One of the two stimulation pumps which are now powering the hydroshearing process in NWG 55-29
10/13
One of the two stimulation pumps which are now powering the hydroshearing process in NWG 55-29
Well NWG 55-29 being drilled in 2008
11/13
Well NWG 55-29 being drilled in 2008
Artist's impression of an EGS electric power plant. Cold water is pumped down the left well, heated in the hot rock fractures of the reservoir, then returned to the surface by the production wells to supply the power plant (Image: DOE)
12/13
Artist's impression of an EGS electric power plant. Cold water is pumped down the left well, heated in the hot rock fractures of the reservoir, then returned to the surface by the production wells to supply the power plant (Image: DOE)
A plan to tap the thermal energy of the Newberry Volcano is under way (Photo: Joshua Schreiner)
13/13
A plan to tap the thermal energy of the Newberry Volcano is under way (Photo: Joshua Schreiner)

Having successfully negotiated the challenging regulatory slopes of the U.S. Bureau of Land Management, the U.S. Forest Service, the U.S. Department of Energy, and a host of Oregon state agencies, the Newberry Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) demonstration project is in the process of creating a new geothermal reservoir in central Oregon. The core of the new reservoir is a two mile (3.2 km) deep well drilled about four miles (6.3 km) from the center of Newberry Volcano. The rock surrounding the wellbore reaches temperatures in the order of 600° F (315° C), and is nearly impermeable to water. That, however, is about to change.

Newberry Volcano is one of the largest and youngest volcanoes in the United States. Having last erupted about 1,300 years ago, it consists of over 400 individual volcanic vents, which, when combined, form a broad mounded landform referred to as a shield volcano. The Newberry EGS Demonstration geothermal reservoir is being formed in the high-temperature, low-permeability deep lava of the volcano's northwest flank.

The Newberry EGS demonstration project is located near the boundaries of the Newberry National Volcanic Monument
The Newberry EGS demonstration project is located near the boundaries of the Newberry National Volcanic Monument

The Newberry EGS demonstration is the largest project funded to date by the DOE Geothermal Technologies Program. The DOE has granted over US$20 million to the project, an amount being matched by a partnership between AltaRock Energy and Davenport Newberry.

Artist's impression of an EGS electric power plant. Cold water is pumped down the left well, heated in the hot rock fractures of the reservoir, then returned to the surface by the production wells to supply the power plant (Image: DOE)
Artist's impression of an EGS electric power plant. Cold water is pumped down the left well, heated in the hot rock fractures of the reservoir, then returned to the surface by the production wells to supply the power plant (Image: DOE)

The goal of EGS is to produce electricity by extracting energy from the earth’s heat. To accomplish this, a subsurface system of fractures is formed in hot, impermeable rock, and water pumped down from the surface is circulated through these fractures and returned to the surface as the energy source for a geothermal power plant.

The starting point for creating a new geothermal reservoir is a deep well into hot, dry rock. Well NWG 55-29, drilled by Davenport Newberry in 2008, is well suited as the foundation for a geothermal reservoir. It is 10,060 feet (3066 m) deep into hot rock with very low water permeability.

Preexisting cracks in the deep rock are expanded by hydroshearing. The original, essentially closed crack appears at the left. In the center, the crack is opened by water pressure, whereupon the faces slip a bit along the length of the crack. When the water is removed, the crack faces no longer match, so the crack remains permeable to the flow of water
Preexisting cracks in the deep rock are expanded by hydroshearing. The original, essentially closed crack appears at the left. In the center, the crack is opened by water pressure, whereupon the faces slip a bit along the length of the crack. When the water is removed, the crack faces no longer match, so the crack remains permeable to the flow of water

Creating an EGS reservoir requires improving the natural permeability of the hot rock at depth. The process chosen by the Newberry EGS project is called stimulation, in which the natural permeability of deep rock is improved by causing small slips to occur in existing cracks, thereby opening a network of small cracks already present in the rock. This hydroshearing process differs significantly from the hydraulic fracturing used in oil and gas recovery – only enough pressure (about 1600 psi, or 10.9 MPa) is applied to open existing cracks, but not nearly enough (over 5000 psi, or 34 MPa) to form new cracks. In addition, hydroshearing uses only water: the chemical additives used in fracking are not required.

NWG 55-29 has a well casing to a depth of 6,462 feet (1,970 m), after which the well is open to the surrounding rock. This structure is important for the formation of an effective geothermal reservoir. If part of the network of cracks is formed at too shallow a depth, the surrounding rock will be cold, and the production wells will deliver a mix of hot and cold water, resulting in less effective extraction of energy and more complex power plant designs which are able to work at lower temperatures. With the casing, fracture networks will be formed for NWG 55-29 only below the lowest point of the well casing, at a depth where the surrounding rock is very hot indeed.

There is a problem that appears when creating a very deep geothermal reservoir. It takes less pressure to expand cracks at a depth of 7000 feet (2134 m) than it does at 10,000 feet (3,048 m), owing to the additional weight of the covering rock. Accordingly, the more you pump at pressure, the more crack network you open at 7000 feet, but you will never open substantially deeper cracks – the 7000 foot crack network acts as a pressure safety valve protecting the deeper rock.

The Newberry EGS project will involve three stages of stimulation, or crack network expansion, at different depths to effectively use the power of the hot volcanic rock
The Newberry EGS project will involve three stages of stimulation, or crack network expansion, at different depths to effectively use the power of the hot volcanic rock

AltaRock has developed a clever solution for this problem. Thermo-degradable Zonal Isolation Materials (TZIM) represents an important technological advancement in the development of EGS. TZIM is a biodegradable, non-toxic gel-like material. Mixed with the water being injected into well being converted into a geothermal reservoir during the hydroshearing process, the TZIM material seals the newly expanded crack network when the water is removed. A shield is thus formed around the wellbore so deeper fracture networks can be added to the reservoir. After the desired fracture networks are formed, the seals biodegrade to open the crack networks of the new reservoir. Simulation studies suggest that a series of three fracture networks will be suitable for the Newberry EGS project.

On October 18 the pumping equipment was running and a water pressure of 1600 psi (10.9 MPa) was built up inside NWG 55-29. The diagnostics (pumping rate, microseismic detectors, etc.) indicated that hydroshearing and expansion of a network of cracks in the hot rock had begun. However, an unexpected night of freezing weather on October 20 damaged some of the auxiliary equipment, leading to a temporary shutdown of operations. AltaRock hopes to resume testing the stimulation process later this week. The following video gives a very good (if slightly lengthy) description of the project.

Source: AltaRock Energy

Newberry EGS Demonstration

28 comments
Pete Kratsch
Now that's using your noodle! I love seeing these kinds of projects gaining traction.
Christian Dillon
I'm so glad they successfully negotiated the challenging regulatory slopes of the U.S. Bureau of Land Management.
Pikeman
Strange that they use steam turbines. Sterling cycle engines could use the heat without having to separate the steam from liquid water.
The Hoff
Getting energy out of the ground like this is smart. Apposed to fracking, typically a mix of water, sand, and chemicals, including ones known to cause cancer injected underground at high pressure to fracture the rock surrounding an oil or gas well, which is completely stupid.
Murray Smart
I'm curious as to why they can't just produce tunnels that withstand the pressure down to a distance of which the temperature can instantly boil / steam water ... then just let steam rise up turn turbines, hit a "roof" turn to water and run-off back down the tunnel? this would require no pumping to achieve and would be able to run continuously at a much more shallow distance than proposed for free (turbine and pressure resistant tunnel maintenance aside.)
livin_the_dream
I can see why this got approved, at the end of the video he states it will generate not only electricity but more importantly TAX REVENUE. Don't get me wrong, this is great that it is non-polluting, I'm all for it. Just really annoys me that other projects, that would cost the consumer less do not get developed because there would be no way to TAX them. I guess that's the world we live in, keep fuel controlled centrally.
Jules Tipler
Love reading stories like this. The world needs more clever innovation and engineers / scientists to make it happen, JT
Dawar Saify
Easier said than done. The cracks can't be predicted as well, errant pressure build ups can cause small earthquakes. If many of these are built overtime, this could start cooling the earth's crust, causing earthquakes in some parts of the world as pressure builds up. It could activate older pressures as a pathway is made to the hot layers. Water will find a way to hot areas and build pressure. Geothermal energy is not that easy.
Charlie Channels
Geothermal energy is the most feasible-efficient-most abundant-greenest kind of energy available to us. In fact, it alone could power all humankind needs for a few hundred years to come. There would be absolutely no need for nuclear, solar, wind energy at all (won't even consider internal combustion engines). Why isn't it appropriately developed now, on this 21st century, when so much has been achieved? By simple SELFISHNESS and GREED of corporations, which support a worldwide obsolete economic model based on debt and wars (yep, the most lucrative business of them all). Check out "Zeitgeist" (including the "addendum" and "moning forward"). Plain, simple and honest truth...
Natano
One question i would ask is what could possibly go wrong? Steam explosions? Lava dome collapse? Good thing they've thought all this thru. Of course putting a 4' windmill on every telephone pole would generate giga watts of power but that would decentralize the power grid and possibly lead to an abundance of energy. This exotic stuff is much better. If people realized simple solutions are the way out of complex problems, that might inspire people to look at our political system and determine that paper ballots would fix these weird election anomalies like what we've seen in the last 15 years.