Aircraft

World-first aerospike rocket flight test ends in disaster

World-first aerospike rocket flight test ends in disaster
The MIRA I craft suffered just enough crash damage to not be worth salvaging, with the company instead moving on to the MIRA II and III
The MIRA I craft suffered just enough crash damage to not be worth salvaging, with the company instead moving on to the MIRA II and III
View 12 Images
The MIRA I looking
1/12
The MIRA I appearing pretty official. The surface of that runway looks as though it may have played a part in the MIRA I's demise
POLARIS Spaceplanes test-fire of its AS-1 rocket engine
2/12
POLARIS Spaceplanes test-fire of its AS-1 rocket engine
The MIRA I prototype, shown in what's presumably a screenshot taken from video moments before its unscheduled disassembly
3/12
The MIRA I prototype, shown in what's presumably a screenshot taken from video moments before its unscheduled disassembly
The Polaris MIRA I
4/12
The Polaris MIRA I
This test of twin Rocketdyne XRS-2200 Linear Aerospike engines, originally built for Lockheed Martin's X-33 program, was performed on August 6, 2001, at NASA's Stennis Space Center
5/12
This test of twin Rocketdyne XRS-2200 Linear Aerospike engines, originally built for Lockheed Martin's X-33 program, was performed on August 6, 2001, at NASA's Stennis Space Center
MIRA I undergoing preflight checks
6/12
MIRA I undergoing preflight checks
Test firing the AS-1 LOX/kerosene linear aerospike rocket engine in a closed environment
7/12
Test firing the AS-1 LOX/kerosene linear aerospike rocket engine in a closed environment
The MIRA I taxis down the runway
8/12
The MIRA I taxis down the runway
The MIRA I craft suffered just enough crash damage to not be worth salvaging, with the company instead moving on to the MIRA II and III
9/12
The MIRA I craft suffered just enough crash damage to not be worth salvaging, with the company instead moving on to the MIRA II and III
The Polaris Spaceplanes team looking proud of what they've accomplished thus far
10/12
The Polaris Spaceplanes team looking proud of what they've accomplished thus far
Polaris eventually hopes to build reusable spaceplanes for cargo and passenger transport
11/12
Polaris eventually hopes to build reusable spaceplanes for cargo and passenger transport
A traditional bell-style rocket vs aerospike rocket
12/12
A traditional bell-style rocket vs aerospike rocket
View gallery - 12 images

It was set to be the world's first flight test for an aerospike rocket engine, but the MIRA I prototype crashed on takeoff before the most innovative part of its propulsion system could fire. Undeterred, Polaris is building two bigger prototypes.

The MIRA I, from German aerospace startup Polaris Raumflugzeuge, was traveling at approximately 105 mph (169 km/h) during takeoff when a "landing gear steering reaction" plus a side wind caused a "hard landing event," rendering the space plane inoperable and its fiberglass airframe damaged beyond repair.

Its subsystems remained mostly intact – however, rather than attempt to repair the prototype spaceplane, Polaris has opted to decommission the 4.25-meter (13.9-ft) long MIRA I to go ahead with the identically shaped 5 m (16 ft) MIRA II and III design. Basically larger copies of the MIRA I.

The MIRA I looking
The MIRA I appearing pretty official. The surface of that runway looks as though it may have played a part in the MIRA I's demise

This ill-fated test was set to be MIRA I's first chance to fire its AS-1 LOX (Liquid Oxygen)/kerosene linear aerospike rocket engine in actual flight – and indeed, the first time any aerospike engine had been properly flight-tested in an actual aircraft.

Yes, an aerospike rocket engine, developed in-house by Polaris. If that sounds like something from science fiction, well, it almost is. They were first invented in the 1950s by Rocketdyne, but have never been used outside of a lab.

The MIRA I prototype, shown in what's presumably a screenshot taken from video moments before its unscheduled disassembly
The MIRA I prototype, shown in what's presumably a screenshot taken from video moments before its unscheduled disassembly

The easiest way to imagine an aerospike engine is to take a conventional bell-shaped rocket engine nozzle, and more or less turn it inside-out, making the inner cross section half of the bell shape and leaving the outside open to the atmosphere.

Comparison of a conventional rocket engine and an aerospike
Comparison of a conventional rocket engine and an aerospike

Why? Traditional bell-shaped rockets can only operate at peak efficiency at a specific altitude, defined by the shape and size of the bell. As the rocket goes higher in altitude, the atmospheric pressure decreases and efficiency drops – thus requiring different rocket stages, using different bell shapes and sizes for different phases of a launch.

In lab tests, the aerospike engine design can get around this issue. Effectively, aerospike designs use the ambient atmospheric pressure around the rocket as the external wall of their nozzles. The changing pressure at different altitudes combines with aerodynamic effects to change the size and shape of the envelope of air pressure around the engine, pushing the fiery goodness of the expanding gases back against the cross section of the half-bell to create more pressure, speed up the exhaust and focus the thrust.

So while a conventional rocket will be more efficient within its operational limits, aerospike designs maintain a strong average efficiency from sea level all the way up to the vacuum of space, self-compensating as pressure levels change without the need for extra moving parts.

An aerospike engine being ground tested
An aerospike engine being ground tested

While the MIRA I didn't get a chance to prove this technology in flight, the new MIRA II and III will feature the same propulsion layout: four kerosene jet turbines and the single AS-1 aerospike rocket engine that were equipped on MIRA I. The main difference is the size of the airframes; go big or go home, right?

Test firing the AS-1 LOX/kerosene linear aerospike rocket engine in a closed environment
Test firing the AS-1 LOX/kerosene linear aerospike rocket engine in a closed environment

Another factor that makes the MIRA project different is its delta-wing airframe, designed to be completely reusable for transport to and from orbit. If all goes to plan, it will be able to carry payloads or passengers as a fully-functional, reusable, Single Stage To Orbit (SSTO) spaceplane.

Polaris eventually hopes to build reusable spaceplanes for cargo and passenger transport
Polaris eventually hopes to build reusable spaceplanes for cargo and passenger transport

In a press release posted to LinkedIn by Polaris Spaceplanes, the company keeps things positive: "At Polaris, we are advancing our project at an exceptionally rapid pace. To facilitate such swift progress, we fully accept that sometimes things can break... If you don’t break things, you are not ambitious enough."

Source: Polaris

View gallery - 12 images
7 comments
7 comments
Tristan P
Looks cool!
Bob809
It has always been said that helping to craft the future comes with consequences. At least they have higher plans waiting to go. Best of luck to them.
Eureka...Kablaammm!
Perfect use of the word groundbreaking - referencing an aircraft that drilled in. I don't think I would use that word to promote the next flight(!)
Global
2 steps forward one step back, net still advancing...
Eureka...Kablaammm!
Very risky promoting aircraft as "GroundBreaking" especially after drilling one in!!! Literally groundbreaking.
Floydninja
I just want to know if there were Requisition Slips or Super Credits in there.....
AWilson
I disagree with the word, "Disaster." I suppose if the builders learned nothing at all, then it was a wasted test, but "disaster?!" How many died? How many were injured? Was the plane a complete write off? The answer to all of these is no. So... it was not a disaster.