Good Thinking

One Big Question: Do you really have to drain your battery periodically to keep it conditioned?

One Big Question: Do you reall...
Is it a good idea to let your phone battery drain completely from time to time?
Is it a good idea to let your phone battery drain completely from time to time?
View 2 Images
Is it a good idea to let your phone battery drain completely from time to time?
1/2
Is it a good idea to let your phone battery drain completely from time to time?
An illustration of how a lithium-ion battery works
2/2
An illustration of how a lithium-ion battery works

All of the smartphones bursting into flames these days has got us thinking a lot about batteries here at the New Atlas offices. Specifically, we were wondering if the need to periodically discharge cell phone batteries to keep them conditioned is really necessary.

So, as part of our regular One Big Question series, we put that very query to Daniel Abraham, a lithium-ion battery specialist at the Argonne National Laboratory outside of Chicago, Illinois. Here's what he had to say on the subject:

Present-day cell phones (and laptops) contain lithium-ion batteries, which do not need to be discharged periodically to keep them "conditioned."

The "discharge periodically" recommendation is a holdover from older kinds of batteries, such as nickel-cadmium and nickel-metal hydride rechargeable batteries. These batteries are believed to display a "memory effect" that causes them to hold less charge if they're not discharged periodically. That's not the case for lithium-ion batteries.

To understand this better it helps to know how rechargeable lithium-ion batteries work.

A rechargeable battery cell contains four basic components: a positive cathode, a negative anode, an electrolyte that allows lithium ions to flow between them, and a separator that physically separates the electrodes to prevent short circuits.

An illustration of how a lithium-ion battery works
An illustration of how a lithium-ion battery works

When you charge the battery, the current from the electrical outlet forces lithium ions to move from the cathode to the anode. This converts electrical energy from the outlet into stored chemical energy. When you unplug the battery and begin to use it, the lithium ions flow back to the cathode; the stored chemical energy is converted into a stream of electrons to power the device.

In commercial lithium-ion cells graphite is typically the active component in the anode. The lithium ions arrange themselves between the graphene planes making them expand and contract. The active component in the cathode is typically lithium-bearing oxide or phosphate particles. The lithium-ions are extracted from these particles when the cell is being charged or inserted into these particles when the cell is being discharged.

This lithium insertion and extraction process, termed intercalation, typically does not alter the crystal structure of the host cathode or anode particles. In an ideal scenario the lithium insertion and extraction process is 100 percent reversible; in reality some lithium-ions are lost in undesired reactions and cell battery performance degrades gradually.

The memory effect in NiCd cell is attributed to the formation and growth of cadmium hydroxide crystals when the cell is held in the fully-charged state for long periods. Periodic deep discharges (or cell conditioning) restore the crystals to their original size and cell performance is often restored.

Commercially available lithium-ion cells are based on intercalation chemistries and do not display such crystal formation and growth.

However, scientists in research laboratories worldwide are working on alternative chemistries to increase the energy and power density of battery cells. Some of these cells are based on a "conversion" process instead of the intercalation process. New crystal structures are formed during the conversion reaction. We do not know whether these future cells will need to be conditioned periodically to maintain performance.

13 comments
JasonBurr
The problem with Lithium-Ion batteries is not the battery itself, but rather the software that provides the gauge of state of charge. Even my laptop has a function the discharges and recharges a couple times to reset the gauge.
unggitsastra
The question that always raised is: given the explanation above (well done!), why do these batts EVENTUALLY hold less and less charge time and that EVENTUALLY do not hold ANY charge at all.
Ken Brody
The anode is plus and the cathode is minus. You got the signs reversed on the diagram.
wle
true one thing that MIGHT help a bit is to let the battery run down a fair amount, say below 20% left then turn the phone OFF and let it charge completely sometimes this helps the ' charge remaining ' calculation to be more accurate wle
Sean-Anthony Sutherland
Does everyday count as periodically, am i the only person who actually uses their phone?
LeeCook
The explanation inferred that the charge process causes a negative lithium ion to migrate through the medium to the negative terminal giving it a negative charge. When the excess electron flows through the load to to the positive terminal to do work this leaves a neutral lithium atom at the negative terminal. Does the charging process cause this neutral lithium atom to migrate back across the medium to be ionized?
LyndaLeepan
New Samsung phones used to recommend a long (overnight) 1st charge and then 5 cycles of full discharge-recharge. Was that to condition earlier Li batteries ?. Not applicable anymore.
EcoLogical
NiCad and NiMH batteries have 'metal' electrodes where the 'metal' is dissolved into the electrolyte during discharge and then (unevenly) electroplated back on during charging. If the battery is shallow cycled multiple times the electroplating process forms 'dendrites' that eventually grow to the point where they short circuit through the electrolyte to the opposite electrode. A periodic deep discharge will dissolve the dendrites returning the electrodes to their original smooth condition. Since Li-ion batteries don't have metallic Lithium dendrite growth does NOT occur and deep discharge is not only unnecessary but can actually damage a Li-ion battery.
rhY
Man, why can't we have Graphene Ultracapacitors by now. They had them in the lab almost a decade ago already. http://www.greenoptimistic.com/how-to-make-graphene-hydrazine-solution-20081112/ Batteries are inferior on every level.
katgod
unggitsastra "in an ideal scenario the lithium insertion and extraction process is 100 percent reversible; in reality some lithium-ions are lost in undesired reactions and cell battery performance degrades gradually."