Energy

How giant concrete balls on ocean floors could store renewable energy

How giant concrete balls on ocean floors could store renewable energy
A 10-ft test sphere being dropped down to the bottom of Lake Constance in Europe
A 10-ft test sphere being dropped down to the bottom of Lake Constance in Europe
View 5 Images
A 10-ft test sphere being dropped down to the bottom of Lake Constance in Europe
1/5
A 10-ft test sphere being dropped down to the bottom of Lake Constance in Europe
A render depicting StEnSea spheres being assembled and sent offshore from a dock
2/5
A render depicting StEnSea spheres being assembled and sent offshore from a dock
An illustration of a StEnSea array for storing power offshore from the grid
3/5
An illustration of a StEnSea array for storing power offshore from the grid
An installation of StEnSea spheres in deep water together with floating wind turbines
4/5
An installation of StEnSea spheres in deep water together with floating wind turbines
Each of these concrete StEnSea spheres is expected to last 50-60 years before it needs replacing
5/5
Each of these concrete StEnSea spheres is expected to last 50-60 years before it needs replacing
View gallery - 5 images

In an effort to reduce the use of precious land to build renewable energy storage facilities, the Fraunhofer Institute has been cooking up a wild but plausible idea: dropping concrete storage spheres down to the depths of our oceans.

Since 2011, the StEnSea (Stored Energy in the Sea) project has been exploring the possibilities of using the pressure in deep water to store energy in the short-to-medium term, in giant hollow concrete spheres sunken into seabeds, hundreds of feet below the surface.

An empty sphere is essentially a fully charged storage unit. Opening its valve enables water to flow into the sphere, and this drives a turbine and a generator that feed electricity into the grid. To recharge the sphere, water is pumped out of it against the surrounding water pressure using energy from the grid.

Each of these concrete StEnSea spheres is expected to last 50-60 years before it needs replacing
Each of these concrete StEnSea spheres is expected to last 50-60 years before it needs replacing

Each hollow concrete sphere measures 30 ft (9 m) in diameter, weighs 400 tons, and will be anchored to the sea floor at depths of 1,970 - 2,625 ft (600 - 800 m) for optimal performance.

Fraunhofer has previously tested a smaller model in Europe's Lake Constance near the Rhine river, and is set to drop a full-size 3D-printed prototype sphere to the seabed off Long Beach near Los Angeles by the end of 2026. It's expected to generate 0.5 megawatts of power, and have a capacity of 0.4 megawatt-hours. For reference, that should be enough to power an average US household for about two weeks.

An illustration of a StEnSea array for storing power offshore from the grid
An illustration of a StEnSea array for storing power offshore from the grid

The bigger goal is to test whether this tech can be expanded to support larger spheres with a diameter of nearly 100 ft (30 m). Fraunhofer researchers estimate StEnSea has a massive global storage potential of 817,000 gigawatt-hours in total – enough to power every one of approximately 75 million homes across Germany, France, and the UK put together for a year.

The institute estimates storage costs at around US5.1¢ (EUR 4.6¢) per kilowatt-hour, and investment costs at $177 (EUR 158) per kilowatt-hour of capacity – based on a storage park with six spheres, a total power capacity of 30 megawatts, and a capacity of 120 megawatt-hours.

An installation of StEnSea spheres in deep water together with floating wind turbines
An installation of StEnSea spheres in deep water together with floating wind turbines

According to Fraunhofer, StEnSea spherical storage is best suited for stabilizing power grids with frequency regulation support or operating reserves, and for arbitrage. The latter refers to buying electricity at low prices and selling it at high market prices – which grid operators, utilities providers, and power trading companies can engage in.

Ultimately, StEnSea could rival pumped storage as a way to store surplus grid electricity, with an obvious advantage: it doesn't take up room on land. Plus, pumped storage only really works when you have two reservoirs at different elevations to drive pumps that act as turbines. While pumped storage is cheaper to run and slightly more efficient over an entire storage cycle, StEnSea can potentially be installed across several locations worldwide to support immense storage capacity.

A render depicting StEnSea spheres being assembled and sent offshore from a dock
A render depicting StEnSea spheres being assembled and sent offshore from a dock

The US Department of Energy has invested $4 million into the project, so it will be keen to see how the 2026 pilot plays out off the California coast.

If you enjoy discovering all the weird ways in which we produce and store energy, see how falling rain can generate electricity, and get a closer look at plans to turn millions of disused mines around the world into massive underground batteries.

Source: Fraunhofer IEE

View gallery - 5 images
5 comments
5 comments
paul314
Can they potentially take advantage of tides in large-swing areas to increase their storage efficiency?
Techutante
Hrmm, interesting. I had an idea involving sinking heavy weights that could have gas pumped into them to make them lighter to pull back out, then the gas could be drained and then could be sunk - pulling a chain. Gravity energy storage assisted by buoyancy. I hadn't considered the reverse, using deep ocean water pressure. I think this is interesting, although I wonder if there is a hazard in stirring the water at that depth. Isn't there a lot of extremely find sediment that settles down there? Would the intakes get blocked by this frequently? Barnacles, deep sea life crawling into the intakes?
anthony88
If the sphere is empty, that would mean that - if made light enough - it could have some buoyancy. Instead of sinking it all the way to the seabed, it could be sunk far enough - but not too far down - to take advantage of wave swells to move the sphere up and down. Attach the sphere to a pump that generates pressure from the movement and there might be enough pressure to empty the sphere and continue the cycle of power generation.
riczero-b
If this had an open base like a bell jar it could also harness the increased pressure from the water at depth .
TechGazer
Concrete seems like a terrible choice for something that's going to be subject to frequent expansion/contraction stresses. "Expected to last 50-60 years" based on what long-term testing data?
Reversing the flow (turbine running on seabed water flowing in, and water then pumped out through top) might be better from some perspectives (a smaller pump could pump it to a point partway to the surface), and pumping it to the surface would boost fertility of the surface water. Hard to deal with the maintenance issues for water intake that far down. The system might be better off as a closed system, with a bladder on the surface to contain biological-free water. This system is effectively just a regular hydroelectric dam created by an artificial "low point", as opposed to the regular dams being artificial high points.