Energy

Solar power project hits the rails with between-track panel pilot

Solar power project hits the rails with between-track panel pilot
Now cleared for a 2025 pilot project, the Sun-Ways solution turns the space between railroad tracks into removable solar power plants
Now cleared for a 2025 pilot project, the Sun-Ways solution turns the space between railroad tracks into removable solar power plants
View 4 Images
Now cleared for a 2025 pilot project, the Sun-Ways solution turns the space between railroad tracks into removable solar power plants
1/4
Now cleared for a 2025 pilot project, the Sun-Ways solution turns the space between railroad tracks into removable solar power plants
The self-contained panels can be connected to the grid, used to power local infrastructure or routed to "the traction energy network that powers locomotives"
2/4
The self-contained panels can be connected to the grid, used to power local infrastructure or routed to "the traction energy network that powers locomotives"
Railway maintenance company Scheuchzer SA has developed a machine to install or remove the Sun-Ways panel modules
3/4
Railway maintenance company Scheuchzer SA has developed a machine to install or remove the Sun-Ways panel modules
The 2025 pilot project recently approved by the Federal Office of Transport will see this 100-m stretch of railways track near the Buttes station transformed into a mini solar power plant with an installed capacity of 18 kWp
4/4
The 2025 pilot project recently approved by the Federal Office of Transport will see this 100-m stretch of railways track near the Buttes station transformed into a mini solar power plant with an installed capacity of 18 kWp
View gallery - 4 images

Even on busy rail networks, the gap between lines can spend much of its time doing little but face skyward, so why not put that space to good use? Swiss startup Sun-Ways is looking to do just that by installing solar panels in between railway tracks.

Despite many household and business rooftops rocking solar panels, and dedicated "farms" also soaking up the Sun's energy, there's still huge potential for harvesting much more.

Sun-ways is looking to tap into the estimated 1-TWh annual energy potential from the 5,000-km of railroad tracks in Switzerland by laying removable PV panels between them. The company states that this could potentially meet the electricity needs of almost a third of the country's public transport sector, while making yearly CO2 savings of more than 200,000 tons.

Sun-Ways.ch - Vidéo 3D _EN

Each "full black" panel measures 1 x 1.7 m (3.3 x 5.5 ft) and features an anti-reflective filter to prevent glare. This is mounted as a multi-array format in a frame where all components and wiring are housed within. The current setup is designed to fit track gauges of 1.43 m (4.6 ft), though this can be adapted for non-standard installations.

The multi-panel modules can be installed and connected manually by engineers, but railway maintenance company Scheuchzer SA has developed a machine capable of installing up to 1,000 m2 of Sun-Ways panel arrays per day.

Railway maintenance company Scheuchzer SA has developed a machine to install or remove the Sun-Ways panel modules
Railway maintenance company Scheuchzer SA has developed a machine to install or remove the Sun-Ways panel modules

The "solar power plant" has been designed so that the panel modules can be temporarily removed while railway engineers perform track maintenance, and then put back down when work has been completed. And the setup has been tested for stability for trains passing overhead at up to 150 km/h (93 mph), and can withstand 240-km/h (150 mph) winds.

Since the panels are laid flat, snowfall during winter months will naturally adversely affect performance. But the company told us that cylindrical brushes could be attached to the ends of trains to deal with the inevitable accumulation of dirt – so it's not a huge leap to come up with something similar to clear snow.

Electricity produced by the system could be used to power nearby infrastructure such as switches or points – or even stations. Of course it could be fed into the grid, or routed to "the traction energy network that powers locomotives" – which negates the need for ground-based inverters.

The self-contained panels can be connected to the grid, used to power local infrastructure or routed to "the traction energy network that powers locomotives"
The self-contained panels can be connected to the grid, used to power local infrastructure or routed to "the traction energy network that powers locomotives"

An application to the Federal Office of Transport (FOT) last year was initially refused, but Sun-Ways labored on – engaging academics from the HEIG-VD (Haute Ecole d'Ingénierie et de Gestion du Canton de Vaud) to undertake independent assessments of custom-built panel prototypes. These were added to the technical and safety documentation produced by Geste Engineering, and the plan resubmitted for approval.

It took 10 months of deliberation, but the FOT has now given the green light to a 2025 pilot on a 100-m (330-ft) stretch of the TransN line 221 near Buttes railway station in he Swiss canton of Neuchâtel. Some 48 panels will be installed between the rails, at a capacity of 18 kWp.

The setup will be connected to the local grid by the electricity distributor Viteus and railway infrastructure outfit DG Rail, and pilot project trains will roll at 70 km/h. Installation and removal tests will be undertaken during the trial, together with more tests and measurements to "ensure that there will be no damaging impact on the railway infrastructure."

Sun-Ways, from vision to reality

Sun-Ways has also announced that it will embark on a feasibility study on a 1,500-m (4,921-ft) section of private track in the municipality of Aigle, with an installed capacity of 288 kWp.

The company is currently in the early stages of setting up another pilot with SNCF in France too, along with others in Spain, Romania and South Korea. Discussions with operators in China, Thailand, Australia and the US are also in the early stages.

Source: Sun-Ways

View gallery - 4 images
16 comments
16 comments
1stClassOPP
If I take a close look at our local train tracks, I observe that they are very dirty, contaminated with grease, oil, dust, generally with all kinds of debris. I do believe it’ll take more than a mere rotating brush to keep the panels clean, which leads to chemical solutions. Still think this is a good idea?
Wavmakr
What could go wrong?............
Deres
Flat on the ground and worst between rails seems a very dusty environnement. Except with a regular costly cleaning, the power will probably decrease quickly. Worst, a railtrack is a dangerous environment (trains are heavy) that increase maintenance cost as you have to coordinate with train management and be sure a running train will not kill your workers.
geofff
Does the road closer surface increase drag on the train, or the smoother surface decrease drag?
Karmudjun
Thanks Paul, but your reporting is incomplete - doesn't anyone walk the rails in Europe? It is nice that their trains could be equipped with brushes to clean the panels as the train passes over them, and so snow could be managed well too (I suppose), but how many footfalls can the panels take before damage renders them less than useless? A fifteen - twentyfive year lifespan of >80% baseline efficiency (baseline is ~ 24% these days) means these panels would have to endure thousands of foot-falls, liters of grease and oil, and untold cubic meters of dirt before replacement - I saw removal and replacement, but not a process for repairing a panel on site or off-site.
veryken
It's a cute, nifty, 5th-grade idea but won't survive nasty America, where vandalism, abuse, and just random accidents happen all the time.
John in OkieLand
This is rather dumb, and a huge waste of money. the RR here at my home, is rebuilding 100s of miles of track, they can't do that with those Solar Panels in the way.... and they sure aren't going to waste money and buy expensive equipment to put down, pick up, Solar Panels when they need to rebuild the tracks.
Jeff7
This would work in Switzerland where people are responsible and intelligent. In New Zealand the ferals would vandalise them overnight.
Gregg Eshelman
It's a better location than covering roads for cars and trucks with solar panels. Train spacing is strictly regulated so solar railroad tracks will be uncovered a large portion of each day. Also, unlike a solar road, the solar panels between rails won't have the weight and impact of thousands of vehicles rolling along on them.

I'd expect the best use of this solar application would be to provide some of the power needed to run an electric train.
Sun-Ways
Thank you all for your comments, questions and doubts about this article.

We've been working on all these topics for over three years and have filed two sets of patents. The prototypes we built were tested by experts in mechanical engineering, and aerodynamic simulations proved the perfect stability of our devices.

We had to find answers to over 150 risks associated with railway operations, and solutions were also found for all the problems associated with lack of inclination, vibration, cleaning, theft, snow, panel strength, etc.

In reality, there is still a technical challenge to be met: injecting the electricity generated between the rails into the train traction network, so that it can be used as a complementary electricity distribution network. Several research institutes are already working on this subject: Vers un smart grid ferroviaire - Bulletin FR

What's more, such a project would never have reached this level of development had it not been supported by recognized partners in the rail and energy sectors.

The total cost of this pilot project may seem high, but it includes all project-related expenses: technical drawings, prototypes, studies, tests, expert appraisals, project management, manufacture of mechanical parts in small series, installation of the power plant, project follow-up for tests and measurements to be carried out throughout operation.

In terms of profitability, the LCOE targeted by Sun-Ways for large-scale projects is 0.08 USD /kWh (with 1,000 hours of sunshine per year). This represents a cost of USD 38,000 (Capex + Opex over 30 years) for 100 meters of track.

Sun-Ways
Load More