Game helps scientists fight ash disease

Game helps scientists fight as...
The Fraxinus game (Image: The Sainsbury Laboratory)
The Fraxinus game (Image: The Sainsbury Laboratory)
View 2 Images
The Fraxinus game (Image: The Sainsbury Laboratory)
The Fraxinus game (Image: The Sainsbury Laboratory)
Effects of ash dieback (Photo: Food and Environment Research Agency)
Effects of ash dieback (Photo: Food and Environment Research Agency)

Playing video games and feeling virtuous may seem almost like a contradiction in terms, but the Sainsbury Laboratory in Norwich, UK has turned gaming into a way to advance science and help protect the environment. The Fraxinus game is a Facebook app that uses player participation to figure out the structure of a fungus genome, as part of a crowdsourcing effort to combat a disease that threatens Britain and Europe’s ash trees.

The frightening thing about diseases is that they have a habit of popping up out of nowhere. Ash dieback is one such disease. The Chalara fungus (Hymenoscyphus pseudoalbidus) first surfaced in Poland in 1992 and wasn't even described until 2006. However, during that time the disease had already spread across northern Europe to the British Isles, where it threatens to destroy up to 95 percent of Britain's ashes.

The Open Ash Die Back project includes the Sainsbury Laboratory, the Genome Analysis Centre, and the John Innes Centre, and is funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC). It's looking at how the fungus kills and how to combat it by studying the nucleotide sequences that make up the fungus genome.

“Understanding tree diseases at the genetic level could provide a chance of recovering from this epidemic, as well as other threats to our native populations, in a way that was not available when we experienced Dutch elm disease,” says principal pathologist at Forest Research Dr. Joan Webber.

Effects of ash dieback (Photo: Food and Environment Research Agency)
Effects of ash dieback (Photo: Food and Environment Research Agency)

Unfortunately, this is an extremely difficult task to carry out directly because DNA analysis can only deal with very small strands and the process destroys those strands. Therefore, the team’s approach is to generate models of the fungus genome and then compare these models to the actual nucleotide strands to see how closely they match.

There’s another “unfortunately” at work here, because this matching is itself an extremely large task involving 60,000,954 nucleotides. That means it needs to be outsourced or, to be more precise, crowdsourced.

Crowdsourcing experiments has come a long way since the SETI project released its screensaver in 1999, to help process data in the search for intelligent life in the Cosmos. Recently, the approach has been used to plot the genome for a new strain of E. Coli that broke out in Germany, as well as many other projects. Most of these have been requests for people to donate time on their computers via screensavers or similar software that does calculations when the machines are otherwise inactive, but that’s not what’s needed to fight ash dieback.

“Computer power alone is not the answer to making the most of our data,” says Dr. Dan MacLean from the Sainsbury Laboratory, who came up with the Fraxinus game. “An awful lot of human expertise and knowledge has to be poured on top and with this game we can start to include the non-specialist.”

The Fraxinus game is named after the ash tree (Fraxinus Excelsior) and has been under development since December 2012 by the firm of Team Cooper. What’s different about it is that it doesn't use the computer to solve the problem at hand, but the player. That’s because humans are very good at pattern detection, so Team Cooper came up with a game that is both addictive and competitive as a way of getting eyes on the screens.

The game consists of a small genome segment and underneath this are the actual strands for comparison. The game provides an approximate match and it’s the player’s job to improve this by moving the sequence right or left and swapping or removing bits. The player with the best match can “claim” the sequence, though higher scorers can take it away. To improve the competitive angle, the player can invite friends to play along. The highest scorers will earn a credit in publications of results.

“Each play of the game will contribute a small but useful analysis,” says MacLean. “The more people who play it, the more accurate the results will be for us and the quicker we can generate the information needed to help our woodlands recover from the current epidemic.”

The game can be found on Facebook.

The BBSRC video below introduces the Fraxinus game.

Source: The Sainsbury Laboratory via BBC

Fraxinus: a Facebook game to crowdsource the fight against ash dieback disease HD

I think this is a great idea and it could be the way of the future in such investigations of genomes.
Kim Holder
I have been playing this game a lot for the past few days. I love simple puzzle games to pass the time. I quite enjoy this one because it is rather challenging without being so complicated it doesn't let your mind relax. Plus it feels good to feel i am actually contributing to something.
I don't understand why they didn't create a Facebook page where players could leave comments. There are a number of things i'd like to say about it, and i have nowhere to do so.
For one, their introduction to the game does a great job of explaining what the scientific mission is, but doesn't explain how to play the game at all. I had to figure it out by myself, and if i hadn't already seen the video in this article that would have been a rather difficult job. The controls are a bit wonky and could be refined - pulling down to delete a leaf often works poorly. There are strategic things to know about playing the game that could save beginners a lot of grief. If you enjoy figuring things like that on your own, great. I bet lots of people would like some help, especially when a pattern they worked hard on is 'stolen' by another player, and they can't figure out why.
I hope the people behind this read the comments here, because i don't know how else to get these thoughts to them, and i fear these easy to fix flaws will drive a large part of their audience away from the game.