Health & Wellbeing

Single-use, biodegradable "Tab Soap" washes away cost barrier to hygiene

Single-use, biodegradable "Tab Soap" washes away cost barrier to hygiene
Researchers have developed a biodegradable "Tab Soap" which may help to improve public health in developing countries
Researchers have developed a biodegradable "Tab Soap" which may help to improve public health in developing countries
View 1 Image
Researchers have developed a biodegradable "Tab Soap" which may help to improve public health in developing countries
Researchers have developed a biodegradable "Tab Soap" which may help to improve public health in developing countries

While the benefits of handwashing for public health are well-known, in some developing countries soap is an unaffordable luxury. Researchers have now developed a single-use, biodegradable soap-on-a-tab that shows great promise in improving public health in areas without access to running water.

Handwashing with soap has always been a simple and highly effective way of preventing the spread of many infectious diseases. While soap and water don’t kill germs, they work by mechanically removing them from your hands.

But access to and availability of soap and water is limited in developing countries such as Tanzania, in East Africa, where a 2020 study of a typical small town found that only 13% of households had handwashing facilities. In 2016, only 7% of households nationally had a fixed place to wash their hands where there was soap and water present.

Using households around Tanzania’s Dar es Salaam and Morogoro regions as their testing ground, researchers developed a novel handwashing technology called Tab Soap. The households had no private water connection or on-site piped water, meaning that residents had to collect water themselves or pay someone to deliver it. And they had at least one child under five and at least one over five.

Based on interviews with members of these households, the researchers set about designing their new handwashing system. The first aim was to create a desirable, feasible and viable handwashing solution that was scalable. The second and most critical aim was to increase rates of handwashing with soap following bathroom use.

Handwashing behavior was evaluated by way of questionnaires, soap seller reports, electronic monitoring and discussions with the soap sellers, which helped the researchers understand the user’s perception of the product and its use. One of the biggest hurdles the researchers faced was how the households viewed soap from a cultural perspective.

“Interestingly, in the case of soap, even an object meant to be clean and to clean dirty things it comes in contact with was perceived to be contaminated,” said the researchers. “The sense of contamination around sharing soap and the usage of water presented two very clear design challenges in being able to keep products near the toilet while assuring individuals that no cross contamination occurs.”

The researchers presented households with five prototypes, which resulted in two concepts – a soap grater, which is used to recycle leftover soap, and personal soap – being eliminated. The most used prototype was the Tab Soap.

Tab Soap comes as tabs of biodegradable bamboo-based textile impregnated with soap. Once the tab is used, it can be discarded in a pit latrine where it will decompose. The tabs come on a roll or in a tear-off version.

The Tab Soap comes on a roll (left) or in a tear-off version (right)
The Tab Soap comes on a roll (left) or in a tear-off version (right)

After trialing the Tab Soap, the feedback was generally positive. Some users, however, didn’t like that the tabs were only for handwashing, whereas ‘normal’ soap could be used for a range of cleaning activities.

“The different kinds of evidence from the field trial – interviews with participants, seller documentation, data logs and field worker interviews – together paint a persuasive picture of use,” the researchers said. “The interviews support the case for these tabs being almost always used for handwashing, which was an important dimension of our objective.”

The researchers consider their Tab Soap has particular advantages. It is single-use, so cross-contamination concerns are less of a worry. It is designed only for handwashing, so it is hard to misuse the product. Its cost is comparable to alternatives such as liquid soap. A single tab can be carried anywhere and used wherever water is available. And because the bamboo-based substrate stays wet, it probably uses less water than other forms of handwashing.

While the study was small, the researchers see potential in their novel handwashing technology.

“Given the importance of hand hygiene in many public health contexts, including pandemic control, we believe this result should attract widespread interest,” the researchers said.

The study was published in the journal PLOS One.

Source: PLOS via EurekAlert!

While kind of interesting the advantages are not that clear over just liquid hand soap that even they admit is not a more expensive solution. Most people tend to prefer liquid soap to bar soap for handwashing anyway as evidenced by the panic over hand soap being hard to find during the pandemic while bar soap remained an available (but still not popular) solution through the shortage. In my experience most people I meet would rather just use the products everyone else uses and might find it degrading to use care-ware products specifically designed for the poorest people in the world as a charity effort.
c w
Liquid soaps cost more in transportation (transporting weight of water and soap), in space (liquid soap takes up more space than equivalent amount of solid soap) and is more difficult to transport and store (solid soap doesn't splosh or need watertight packaging).

The grater concept seems interesting. I wonder if they thought of trying a solid soap that is meant to be transported whole and grated to be stored at its point of use ready-to-use from a dispenser box or shaker.
Such clear advantages as easy to carry as long as you don't get the bamboo carrier wet until you attempt to use it (it says the bamboo stays wet). But nowhere do I see a significant reduction in the bacterial counts or viral particles detected on hands post washing. I would think it should be more significant rather than peeling tabs of soap off a spool that recorded each spin (& usage) with users reporting use after defecating and before eating. Also - this requires water - from a household bucket or dispenser. Quite a unique study of so few individuals.