Before this year, comparing the Galaxy Note to the iPhone was kinda like comparing Shaquille O'Neal to Rhea Perlman. But with Apple's first phablet arriving this year, the iPhone and Note are fighting in the same weight class. Join Gizmag, as we take a hands-on look at the iPhone 6 Plus and Galaxy Note 4.
No matter what else we say in this comparison, the most important thing to ask yourself is which platform you prefer. Both phones are outstanding, and if you already know what you like, I see no reason why either of these phablets should make you switch sides.
If you own an older iPhone, then the 6 Plus is going to feel less like an upgrade, and more like a completely new device. It feels as much like a tiny iPad mini as it does an iPhone on steroids.
... and though the Galaxy Note 4 doesn't, at first glance, look like a huge upgrade over the Note 3, I found that first impression to be deceptive. The Note 4 shows us Samsung at its best: worrying less about the wow factor, and simply making a better phone.
One of the most obvious differences between these two is the Note's stylus. The S Pen gives the Note more of a PDA feel, like a modern-day evolution of the Palm Pilot. There's a sense of precision there that your fingers just can't replicate – and it's a great fit for the phablet form factor.
The Note 4's S Pen is a big step forward from older Notes. No longer do you have to press down hard with the pen; now the lightest of brushes against the screen registers as a swipe. And don't worry, it isn't too sensitive – it just lends a more natural feel to the stylus experience.
Samsung also did a terrific job of refining the software that goes along with the S Pen. The stylus features, for things like jotting handwritten notes and saving content on your screen, have subtle improvements this year (details like dragging a box around your target, rather than having to draw a shape around it, or dropping your notes on your home screen as little post-it-note widgets).
The biggest improvement, though, is S Pen text selection. I'm not sure why Samsung didn't add this to the Note years ago, but you can finally use the stylus to select text, much like you'd do with a mouse on a desktop PC.
The phones are both, of course, huge. Their sizes are also similar, with the iPhone coming in slightly taller (by 3 percent) and about 17 percent thinner. Their weights are also nearly identical. I don't see any reason for these minor differences to sway you one way or the other.
The iPhone has a higher-end build, with its aluminum unibody design, but the Note doesn't feel cheap at all. It has a metal band running around its edge that gives it more of a premium aesthetic than we saw in older Notes. And its back is that same soft-touch pleather material that we saw on the Note 3.
Despite the phones' similar sizes, the Note 4 gives you a 7 percent bigger screen. Both displays are enormous, mind you, but Samsung's gives you a better screen-size-to-phone-size ratio.
There is one area where the Note uses its huge screen better than the iPhone does: Samsung's Multi Window and Pop-up Window let you run apps in split-screen or pop-up windows, much like you would on a desktop PC. They're easy to activate, and you can even drag and drop content between certain apps.
The only real downside to Samsung's multitasking is that it's only compatible with select apps. It's a great feature in theory, but since many third-party apps don't play nicely with it, you might find it easier to just switch apps like you would on any other phone.
Screen quality is top-notch in both devices. The Note's Quad HD screen is noticeably sharper, but the iPhone's display still looks crisp. Both have eye-popping and accurate colors with wide viewing angles. The Note's extra pixels give it the overall advantage, but you can't go wrong with either.
Neither phone is designed to be used with one hand, but for those times when you only have one paw free, both have one-handed modes. Samsung's feels a bit clunkier, shrinking the entire screen into a window the size of a smaller phone's display. The iPhone's one-handed mode ("Reachability") slides the screen down so you can reach high-level targets. It's easier to activate (lightly double-tap the Touch ID sensor), but it doesn't shrink the keyboard like Samsung's does.
Speaking of Touch ID, Apple's awesome sensor is an advantage for the iPhone. The Note 4 also has a fingerprint sensor, and it's quite good: a bit more accurate than it was in older Samsung devices. But since you have to swipe it from one angle, as opposed to just touching it from any angle, like on the iPhone, Apple's is the better choice.
Touch ID also has more third-party app support than Samsung's sensor does. Password managers like 1Password and Dashlane are an especially great fit.
Both cameras are among the best you'll find in smartphones. I find the Note to take better shots in low-lit conditions (even more so if you turn on its Night Mode setting), while the iPhone takes more colorful flash shots. The Note is also better for zooming, where it merges several shots and combines them automatically into one clearer image.
I can't say selfies are a big part of my life, but if you're one of the many who regularly takes them, the Note 4 has a couple of tricks that could come in handy. Selfie panorama mode lets you squeeze more friends into your shot: just pan the phone back and forth, as it prompts you. There's also a rear-facing selfie mode, that lets you use the Note's higher-resolution rear camera for better self-portraits. Since you can't see the screen, you just hold the phone up, wait for the beep to let you know that it detected your face, and say cheese.
Battery life isn't a concern on either phone, but the Note should last a little longer. In our test, where we stream video over Wi-Fi with brightness set at 75 percent, the Note dropped around 10 percent per hour, while the iPhone dropped about 12 percent per hour.
If your Note 4 does run out of juice, it has a fast-charging feature that can juice it up from 0 to 50 percent in around 37 minutes. It also has Samsung's Ultra Power Saving Mode, that keeps your Note on the grid when it's almost out of juice (it turns your screen black & white and limits available apps). UPS Mode can stretch 10 percent battery into an extra day of uptime.
You could say that the Galaxy Note 4 and iPhone 6 Plus are the two best phablets ever made, but I'd take that a step farther: these just might be the two best smartphones ever made.
There are only a handful of things that I'd change about each device:
So far most iPhone 6 Plus apps are like regular iPhone apps that just happen to use more space. I'd like to see developers embrace the phone as more of an iPad mini-mini. With this huge screen, apps can get away with using landscape orientation and side-by-side panels. There isn't much of that right now.
The biggest thing I'd change about the Note 4 is the build quality of the S Pen. The phone itself has a more premium aura this year, and the pen's functionality is better than ever. But the stylus' cheap-feeling plastic just doesn't fit. I would have loved to see an S Pen made of, say, aluminum.
We aren't here to declare hard-and-fast winners, but know that both devices are sitting at the head of the 2014 phablet class. If I had to pick one right now, I'd go with the Note: for its stylus, note-centric software features and unique build. But I'd be just about as happy with the iPhone. Flip a coin.
The most important thing is that you figure out which handset is the better fit for you. If you're still on the fence, you can check out our features/specs comparison from back in September, and our individual reviews of the iPhone 6 Plus and Galaxy Note 4.
... and if you want to cast your net wider, you can check out our 2014 Smartphone Comparison Guide.
All that said, everything else about the device is fantastic. I considered trading for the smaller 6 when it first arrived, but the things I do most (read study notes and surf) are just so good, going back to a smaller screen just wasn't worth losing the real estate.
Another thing I've noticed is my iPad mini retina. More accurately, I've noticed it's absence. I really haven't used it at all. I'm sure the battery has run down by now. I haven't done any significant photography since getting the 6+, but I imagine using PSExpress and Snapseed will be close enough to the iPad experience that this thing will take over that duty, as well. Major processing will still happen on the desktop.
In short, I'm loving the iPhone 6+ as an "everything except a phone" device. Guess it's finally time to find and reacquaint myself with my old Apple BlueTooth headset...
Criticizing Samsung's pen when apple doesn't have one, complimenting apples build when one cannot swap out batteries, Samsung's screen is better but who cares, they're both good enough. Samsung's screen is bigger, but they are both big enough, both batteries are huge so it's not important that Samsung's is bigger. A coin toss? Is this a review or just how a reviewer keeps a job?
It's not just phones, though. Some car magazines absolutely can't burst the bubble about Germany producing the best cars. One mag had a round-up that included taking American sports sedans onto the Autobahn. In the round-up a German test driver was willing to concede that the American Cadillac CTS-V coupe handled better at fast speeds than the BMW in the comparison. Based on all the scoring, the Cadillac would have won. However, the American writing the piece decided to give the Caddy a lower score in the subjective appearance category for two reasons: 1) a light indicating the manual release for the electric doors, required by the government and a lifesaver if the car should end up in water and the doors short out, and 2) he DIDN'T FEEL THE SOUND OF THE TURN SIGNALS WAS AGRESSIVE ENOUGH.
For perspective, the interior of the coupe and sedan models of the Caddy were identical (other than the electric door/light) and the same magazine had given a higher score in a similar test to the sedan's interior. Nowhere in any of the articles about the Caddy in its various incarnations did any reviewer even mention the turn signals. In fact, one commenter stated he'd subscribed to the magazine for over 10 years and couldn't recall any article in that time mentioning the turn signal sound of any car! The points shaved off were just enough to give the BMW a one or two point paper-thin win over the American car!
Maybe it's like the case with lemmings going over cliffs - they don't. One documentary crew found such backlash from suggesting that they really don't that they actually asked a producer if they should throw a few over a cliff and film it just to make the viewers happy (the producer rejected that idea). It could be reviewer bias but it could also be not wanting to deal with the backlash of debunking a piece of conventional wisdom, be it the superiority of Apple or BMW or lemmings' migratory habits.
I purchased the Japanese ersion of the Edge- a whole different world. I am using the edge for my mostlly used apps and nothing is on my screen.