Automotive

The Leyat Helica propeller car: A wonderfully bad idea

The Leyat Helica propeller car...
One of Marcel Leyat's extraordinary Helica propeller cars came out for the 2020 concours of Elegance
One of Marcel Leyat's extraordinary Helica propeller cars came out for the 2020 concours of Elegance
View 4 Images
One of Marcel Leyat's extraordinary Helica propeller cars came out for the 2020 concours of Elegance
1/4
One of Marcel Leyat's extraordinary Helica propeller cars came out for the 2020 concours of Elegance
A 1922 Leyat Helica in an automotive useum
2/4
A 1922 Leyat Helica in an automotive useum
"Sports" models exposed the driver and tandem passenger to the full force of the propeller blast, sometimes offering small windshields, sometimes not
3/4
"Sports" models exposed the driver and tandem passenger to the full force of the propeller blast, sometimes offering small windshields, sometimes not
Not a sight you'd want to see coming at you on a Zebra crossing
4/4
Not a sight you'd want to see coming at you on a Zebra crossing
View gallery - 4 images

The Concours of Elegance at Hampton Court Palace in the UK is an extraordinary event that blends high society with all sorts of fascinating auto machinery. But among more than a century's worth of motoring history, one machine really rang the bell on our trusty WTF-meter.

This is a 1921 Leyat Helica, one of 30 that Frenchman Marcel Leyat ever built, and of those only 23 reportedly ever sold. Leyat was a biplane designer before World War 1 broke out, but turned his hand to automobile designs, feeling that the aviation world had a thing or two to teach car designers.

First off, he saw early car designs as far too heavy and aerodynamically inefficient, problems that the aviation world had been working hard to solve. Secondly, he felt that driven wheels were another power-sapping exercise in needless complexity, requiring transmissions and clutches and drive shafts and differentials and all sorts of other bits and pieces.

"Sports" models exposed the driver and tandem passenger to the full force of the propeller blast, sometimes offering small windshields, sometimes not
"Sports" models exposed the driver and tandem passenger to the full force of the propeller blast, sometimes offering small windshields, sometimes not

Aircraft, on the other hand, were designed to be aerodynamic and lightweight from the get go, and a propeller could mount more or less directly to the engine's crankshaft. So why not a wingless airplane for the road? These were early days for the automotive industry, and all sorts of different technologies were being thrown at the wall to see which would stick and which would slide.

Horsepower was a fairly scarce resource back in 1913 when Leyat built his first Helica, which used an 18-horsepower, 1,000cc Harley-Davidson v-twin engine in a lightweight plywood body that weighed just 550 lb (250 kg). His goal was to extract motion from that power in the most efficient way possible. In that respect, he did pretty well; a subsequent Helica recorded a top speed of 106 mph (171 km/h) in 1927, a terrifying speed for the time.

In other respects, Leyat's propeller car, and several other designs not dissimilar to it, were a roundly awful idea from the beginning, because, well, they had great big propellers on the front of them. While this example is wire mesh shielded, that doesn't appear to have been a feature of the original designs, so errant pedestrians and wayward pigeons alike could end up getting fed through a several thousand-rpm blender, showering driver and passenger with an exuberance of gore.

A 1922 Leyat Helica in an automotive useum
A 1922 Leyat Helica in an automotive useum

What's more, the spinning mass of the wooden prop could turn into a highly energetic constellation of airborne shrapnel in the event of a rear-ender. When it wasn't exploding in an accident, it was making one more likely by obscuring the driver's view and blowing wind directly into his face at high speed. And if that weren't enough, Leyat had also taken an aircraft-inspired approach to the steering, eschewing the complexities of a steering rack for a very simple, cable-operated rear wheel steering system that threw the back end out sideways to turn the car.

The resulting vehicle looks, shall we say, rather exciting to drive, and thanks to the contemporary footage below assembled by Diagonal View, we can get an idea of how it handled. In even a slow-speed u-turn, the inside rear wheel lifts merrily off the ground, its front wheels wobble around like pin-fixed discs on a toy car, and the whole contraption does little to make us think propeller cars were ever the automobiles of the future.

Source: Concours of Elegance / Lane Motor Museum / Popular Mechanics

View gallery - 4 images
16 comments
Username
I seems they hadn't figured out pusher props yet.
vince
The inventors should have put the prop in the back of the plane like hydrofoils do. And then use it like a rudder to turn the vehicle as well. But reverse gear is a no brainer and wouldn't exist--at least not with gas motors.
windykites
Swamp buggies have taken this idea to the water, successfully.
How about having a horizontal prop under the floor, acting as a ducted fan? (not in a swamp buggy!)
anthony88
If he'd put two engines on the front and two at the back with the drive shafts perpendicular to the horizontal axis and added 4 propellors, he could have beaten every other company trying the same thing by 100 years.
riczero-b
You could truly blow away the opposition in this..
NewThings
Awesome, simply Awesome.
paul314
The electric version would be quieter, and I bet you could fit a much-higher efficiency prop/shroud nowadays. Am I right in observing that the original models had no suspension whatsoever?
piperTom
I'm also a fan of using a pusher prop to help with many of the objections. As for reverse, just tip the blades over and the same rotation pulls it backward. Even so, it's a wonderful an doomed idea.
David V
I saw one of these at Montlhery Speed Week near Paris in 2015. What a blast. And it was actually racing around the circuit ! There were many great old cars there - all pre-war of course but this was something else to see. Absolutely crazy idea but awesome. I'm sure it'll be there for the next edition in 2021.
foxpup
Would be loud as hell, just like swamp-boats. Imagine the noise of even one on a city street. Then think of a bunch of them. Imagine the blasts of wind that pedestrians would have to put up with. Then there's the hazard of the spinning props at hand/head/etc. level. I dont see any drum or disc brakes either.