Energy

Super-cheap gigawatt-scale rust battery greenlit for Minnesota

Super-cheap gigawatt-scale rust battery greenlit for Minnesota
These iron-air "rust batteries" are big and slow, but they're safe and eco-friendly, and store energy at a tenth the cost of lithium
These iron-air "rust batteries" are big and slow, but they're safe and eco-friendly, and store energy at a tenth the cost of lithium
View 6 Images
These iron-air "rust batteries" are big and slow, but they're safe and eco-friendly, and store energy at a tenth the cost of lithium
1/6
These iron-air "rust batteries" are big and slow, but they're safe and eco-friendly, and store energy at a tenth the cost of lithium
Each cell looks like a large, flat sheet. Several are mounted together into a battery module, and many modules are deployed in an installation
2/6
Each cell looks like a large, flat sheet. Several are mounted together into a battery module, and many modules are deployed in an installation
The full-sized modules encompass arrays of many cells
3/6
The full-sized modules encompass arrays of many cells
The batteries charge and discharge using iron's rust cycle
4/6
The batteries charge and discharge using iron's rust cycle
Test and pilot manufacturing facilities are already in place. Ground was broken on a US$760-million large-scale manufacturing facility in West Virginia in May this year.
5/6
Test and pilot manufacturing facilities are already in place. Ground was broken on a US$750 million large-scale manufacturing facility in West Virginia in May this year
Multi-day lulls in solar generation capacity are where batteries like Form's will shine
6/6
Multi-day lulls in solar generation capacity are where batteries like Form's will shine
View gallery - 6 images

Gates- and Bezos-backed startup Form Energy is one of the most exciting companies in the grid-level renewable energy storage space, with a multi-day iron-air battery system just 10% the cost of lithium. A 10-MW/1-GWh demo system has now been approved.

For large electrical grids to move toward 100% renewable energy, grid operators need clever, affordable, practical and eco-friendly ways to store up energy that's generated at inconvenient times, and then release it when demand is outstripping supply.

This needs to happen on different timescales; some of this grid smoothing needs to happen on a daily basis, and that's an area where lithium "big battery" projects are already doing a great job. But lithium is less suited to longer-duration storage; it doesn't like staying fully charged for days or months at a time, so other, slower, bulk storage options are being developed to buffer energy grids against multi-day bad weather spells and seasonal lulls in renewable generation.

Multi-day lulls in solar generation capacity are where batteries like Form's will shine
Multi-day lulls in solar generation capacity are where batteries like Form's will shine

Form Energy is working in the multi-day space, commercializing a relatively simple, modular battery solution based around the rust cycle of iron. Charging these washing-machine-sized battery modules up uses electricity to convert rust, or iron oxide, into metallic iron, and releases oxygen as a by-product. Discharging the batteries requires oxygen to be put back into the system, and turns the metallic iron to rust, releasing energy in the process.

Obviously, this reaction is slower than the instant, high-power discharge of a lithium battery. But it's quicker than you might think; a full discharge cycle takes about 100 hours, or a little over four days. That's right about the sweet spot for the kind of multi-day batteries cities will need to buffer against bad weather. Well, in some places. Sorry, London.

The advantages of an iron-air battery are simple and clear. Direct reduced iron is the cheapest form of iron available, and was previously mainly used in steelmaking. It's extremely abundant, and totally safe. So are water and air, the other two main ingredients.

The batteries charge and discharge using iron's rust cycle
The batteries charge and discharge using iron's rust cycle

These cells might take up some volume – you need about an acre (0.4 ha) of land for 3 MW of power generation, but they last for ages, and they're totally recyclable; you can pull the iron out again and easily sell it on. The result is a Levelized Cost of Storage (LCoS) that comes in at about 10% of a lithium big battery array per kilowatt-hour stored and released.

After announcing a US$760 million manufacturing plant in West Virginia earlier this year, Form Energy has now announced an impressive demonstration project: a 10-megawatt/1-gigawatt-hour system to be built on 5 acres (2 ha) of land near the Sherburne County Generating Station in Becker, Minnesota.

This location puts it conveniently close to Sherco Solar, one of the largest solar generating sites under development in the USA, with a total capacity of 710 MW when it's complete. The battery will be built on a site owned by Xcel Energy, a power company that operates several coal-fired plants, but that's already moved more than half its generating capacity to renewable sources.

Test and pilot manufacturing facilities are already in place. Ground was broken on a US$760-million large-scale manufacturing facility in West Virginia in May this year.
Test and pilot manufacturing facilities are already in place. Ground was broken on a US$750 million large-scale manufacturing facility in West Virginia in May this year

This demonstration battery is a pilot for a program in which Xcel will begin using iron-air batteries to replace its coal-fired power plants, in a way that makes use of existing transmission infrastructure, but that should also keep energy release costs down to about what local grids are already paying for coal-fired grid-firming electricity.

“Multi-day battery storage has the potential to help us better harness the renewable energy we generate while ensuring the grid remains reliable for our customers,” said Bria Shea, a senior VP at Xcel, in a press release. “We look forward to bringing this system online at our Sherco site and learning more about the role it can play in our larger effort to reach 100% carbon-free electricity.”

Construction is set to begin next year, and the battery is slated to come online in 2025. This won't be Form's first grid-connected project; a smaller 1.5-megawatt system is planned with Great River Energy, also in Minnesota. Learn more in the video below.

Form Energy’s Virtual Lab Tour

Source: Form Energy via Recharge News

View gallery - 6 images
12 comments
12 comments
-dphiBbydt
Looking forward to a 80-100kWhr residential unit.
dave be
-dphiBbydt was thinking that too. These might also be really good for putting in as neighborhood microgrids. Most power outtages are under that discharge timeframe, and a lot of times come from a disconnect outside that neighborhood. Each neighborhood could use these to maintain local power while whatever repair work is being done and save a lot of customers the outtage time.
SteveMc
Considerable real estate required, so surely a no-brainer to build these into underground silos or bunkers? Obvious added benefits are natural cooling/stable temperature at depth and fire containment.
Malcolm Jacks
As it need's such a large area i hope they cover the roof's with solar panels. Or build up-wards to save on ground area, especially in places where ground area is at a premium.
ljaques
Interesting cost, but "they last for ages" isn't a very scientific number of cycles (or energy density) which can be compared to other battery lifetimes/powers. I wish they'd given you better numbers.
The Doubter
A very welcome breakthrough. A few things stand out - first, it is technologically uncomplicated unlike some pretty convoluted battery types, second, it has already passed into implementation stage, third, its disadvantages are manageable. Looking forward to further installations.
rbhall52
It's great to have this energy storage technology, but our conventional energy technologies, coal, oil, nuclear, and natural gas, are all doing well with the environment, so we don't need to replace them, ever. I'm all for using all possible technologies to produce energy, but we don't need to convert our country away from the conventional energy technologies that have given the whole world better health and so many unbelievable technologies as it is.
TechGazer
To 1jaques, from what I've read, nickel-iron batteries that are ~100 years old are still working fine, so these iron electrodes might "last for ages". The physical changes to the electrodes might be non-destructive, and thus not affected by number of cycles.

It certainly sounds like a good solution. When my present pair of lead-acid cells wears out, I'd love to replace them with a (cost competitive) iron-air battery that will last the rest of my life.

To rbhall52, I don't see how fossil fuels are "doing well with the environment". Aside from non-CO2 pollution, there's damage to underground water systems, earthquakes from fracking, environment destruction (I'm surrounded by cleared areas for oil/gas wells, access roads, seismic cutlines, etc), propagation of invasive species (lots of invasive weeds on those roads and wellsites). As for CO2, no one has actually solved the problem of release from stored carbon, so the effects of that continues to build.
PJ Dee
Any form of energy storage has its chance for fire, explosion, melting down. I am going to assume these are thin membrane, lots of surface area.
I'd like to read more about the downside.
Augdog
So, form’s batteries have a round trip efficiency of around 35%. Charging efficiency is 90% which is good but discharging is 40%. This means that a 10 MW nameplate output can actually take 30ish MW of charging. These batteries only exist to help smooth out coal ramping when more mills come online. That’s the WV angle, think of these batteries as add-ons to keep coal power relevant in a highly variable renewable future— any talk of renewables storage is greenwashing. There’s a reason these Form batteries are at huge investor-owned coal plants…
Load More