Energy

Orbital reflectors could boost solar energy around dusk and dawn

View 5 Images
Multiple orbital reflectors could deliver usable solar energy to the surface right when it's most needed each day
Andrea Viale/University of Glasgow & NASA
Multiple orbital reflectors could deliver usable solar energy to the surface right when it's most needed each day
Andrea Viale/University of Glasgow & NASA
The Solspace team has investigated the practicalities of an orbital reflector system in a new paper
University of Glasgow
Twilight to solar-generating daylight thanks to multiple orbital reflectors
University of Glasgow
The large reflectors could be aimed in orbit using electric gyroscopes
University of Glasgow
The mirrors would direct sunlight to large solar arrays on the surface, then turn away when out of range
University of Glasgow
View gallery - 5 images

Power demand spikes in the early morning and later evening, when solar arrays can't help. But researchers in Scotland say orbital launch costs are getting so cheap that giant space-based reflectors could soon be a viable way to power these timeslots.

You could possibly look at this as a different way to do space solar – but instead of putting giant photovoltaic arrays in the sky and trying to beam the power down to Earth, you're just hanging big mirror structures in orbit, and using them to send more solar energy down to the surface for harvesting by terrestrial installations.

These orbital reflectors are a very old idea – indeed, Hermann Oberth proposed something very similar in his 1929 book Ways to Spaceflight, which he saw as a potential way of lighting cities, protecting crops from overnight frost, and maybe even keeping entire areas of the far North ice-free, making them more habitable through their gruelling dark winters.

Mind you, he also warned that such devices could be used to concentrate solar energy onto smaller areas for military purposes: "munitions factories can be exploded with it, tornadoes and thunderstorms produced, marching troops and their reserves destroyed, whole cities burned, and generally the greatest of damage done." But we'll leave that aside for the minute!

The mirrors would direct sunlight to large solar arrays on the surface, then turn away when out of range
University of Glasgow

What's more, Russian scientists proved that the concept was possible back in 1993, when their 20-m (66-ft) Znamya-2 space mirror reflected a dim flash of light down to Earth that was visible in the night sky from parts of Europe.

A University of Glasgow team believes that now's the right time to give solar reflectors a serious crack, since SpaceX and other private companies promise they'll soon drive the per-kilogram cost of orbital launches down low enough that these reflectors could be commercially viable.

Here's the rough idea of what the researchers are calling the Solspace project: you'd send a number of reflector satellites into a high, sun-synchronous orbit designed to track over roughly the same ground path each day. This path would be chosen to make the reflectors visible from as many large terrestrial solar farms as possible.

The large reflectors could be aimed in orbit using electric gyroscopes
University of Glasgow

Each satellite would deploy a hexagonal reflector made from aluminized Kapton, with each side measuring 250 m (820 ft) for a total area of 162,380 sq m (1.75 million sq ft).

These reflectors could be steered and aimed in orbit using four electrically powered control moment gyros in a pyramid configuration; by accelerating and decelerating these gyros, you could rotate the entire reflector in any direction.

With the reflectors sitting at an orbital altitude around 900 km (roughly twice as high as the ISS), the team says each mirror pass could illuminate a 10 sq km (3.9 sq mile) area on the surface for about 17 minutes, delivering somewhere around 34-36 MWh of bonus energy to the surface per pass. Thus, large solar farms such as the Sun Cable venture in northern Australia could capture that energy at whatever efficiency they can operate at, generating power during times of peak demand, when otherwise they'd be doing nothing.

The Solspace reflectors would focus on an array as long as they could deliver useful power, then rotate themselves away to deflect the energy off into space until they passed over the next large solar array, hopefully servicing many arrays every day, and potentially even becoming a consideration in the planning of new solar arrays. If a route could be planned to hit 13 large solar farms per day, with five orbital reflectors, the system could deliver 284 MWh of solar energy per day.

Would this cause a light pollution disturbance? No, says the Glasgow team. "Even at its brightest, we estimate that the illumination levels would last only a few minutes per reflector and not exceed an overcast day level," writes Solspace project team member Onur Çelik in The Conversation. "This means that, unless you are very close to the solar power farm, the illumination may not even be noticeable most of the time, especially at dawn/dusk times when the sky is already quite bright compared to nighttime."

Twilight to solar-generating daylight thanks to multiple orbital reflectors
University of Glasgow

In this way, orbital reflectors would offer a dawn/dusk power boost to compete with or augment the energy supplied by short-term grid-level energy storage solutions like lithium batteries. Batteries, for reference, currently have a levelized cost of storage (LCoS) somewhere around US$314 per MWh of energy stored and released.

The Solspace project is targeting a levelized cost of energy (LCoE) closer to US$70 for space-reflected solar generation, assuming an operational lifetime around 20 years and launch costs around US$232 per kilogram.

According to Georgetown Security Studies Review, SpaceX 's reusable Falcon 9 rockets have crashed the price of orbital launch down to around US$1,520/kg. The much larger Starship rocket will drop that to less than US$1,000/kg as soon as it begins commercial launch services, and Elon Musk has predicted that once multiple reusable Starships start operating at a high launch cadence, that cost too will drop by as much as 90% within 2-3 years.

The Solspace team has investigated the practicalities of an orbital reflector system in a new paper
University of Glasgow

Now, you might not want to set your watch by a Musk prediction, but SpaceX has certainly already achieved stunning results, opening up all sorts of orbital opportunities that might never have been possible under NASA's launch programs. So while the timeline is almost certainly very optimistic, it seems fair to expect that the US$232/kg launch costs Solspace needs will be realized in the not too distant future.

So these orbital solar reflectors could certainly become viable if all they were doing was feeding a number of large solar farms around the world. As for other uses, like beating back frost, giving crops a little more Sun, city lighting and whatnot... Well, who knows, those might yet be on the table once these things are deployed.

The study is open access in the journal Advances in Space Research.

Source: Solspace via The Conversation

View gallery - 5 images
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Flipboard
  • LinkedIn
5 comments
Nobody
With all the concern about global warming, how much heat will these reflectors add?
Trylon
Combine two concepts. Don't put them on the terminator to redirect light that would otherwise continue off into space. Put them at the L1 Lagrange point so they can redirect light during the hottest part of each day off axis to the solar farms in the twilight zone. Two for the price of one: a sunshield for less daytime heating to combat global warming and simultaneously reflectors increasing solar farm output. And being on the daylight half of the Earth, they wouldn't cause light pollution or interference with astronomy.
TechGazer
To answer Nobody's question, the total amount of heat is given as <300 MW in the example, insignificant compared to total solar insolation, and I think typical coal-fired power plants produce about 1000 MW. The total might actually be less, because they'd be blocking sunlight when in between the sun and Earth.
aksdad
Superman and his laser vision could also improve solar panel output around dusk and dawn. And just as plausible. It's fun to play with math and think about orbiting mirrors, space elevators, and Superman.
vince
That's idiotic. It will just increase solar heating of the planet and that's the opposite of what we need to do. We need to be BLOCKING some of the sunlight not increasing it. Instead, use the solar panels that block the sunlight to reduce the planet's heating and same time microwave the power back to Earth directly to electrical storage with no planet heating.