Environment

Carbon-neutral granite-based concrete finds use in towering NYC skyscraper

Carbon-neutral granite-based concrete finds use in towering NYC skyscraper
Designed by Foster + Partners, 270 Park Avenue will be the new global headquarters of banking company JPMorganChase
Designed by Foster + Partners, 270 Park Avenue will be the new global headquarters of banking company JPMorganChase
View 3 Images
The granite-based C-Crete should reportedly cost about the same as traditional Portland-cement-based concrete
1/3
The granite-based C-Crete should reportedly cost about the same as traditional Portland-cement-based concrete
Designed by Foster + Partners, 270 Park Avenue will be the new global headquarters of banking company JPMorganChase
2/3
Designed by Foster + Partners, 270 Park Avenue will be the new global headquarters of banking company JPMorganChase
The new granite-based C-Crete, in place in the upper lobby of 270 Park Avenue
3/3
The new granite-based C-Crete, in place in the upper lobby of 270 Park Avenue
View gallery - 3 images

A new type of carbon-neutral concrete has been commercially used for the first time, in a high-profile skyscraper being built in Manhattan. The binder utilized in the concrete is made of granite instead of traditional greenhouse-gas-emitting limestone cement.

Concrete consists of three main ingredients: cement, an aggregate (such as sand and/or gravel) and water. The cement undergoes a chemical reaction when mixed with the water, ultimately forming a solid that binds the mixture together.

Traditional Portland-style cement is made by grinding up limestone and other raw materials, then heating the resulting powder to temperatures of up to 1,450 ºC (2,642 ºF). Unfortunately, the processes by which that heat is generated produce a lot of carbon dioxide.

What's more, as the heated limestone forms into cement via a process known as calcination, it releases trapped carbon dioxide as a byproduct. The combination of that CO2 and the CO2 produced in the heat-generating process is estimated to be responsible for 5% to 8% of all human-caused greenhouse gas emissions.

Various groups have set out to reduce cement's carbon footprint by replacing the limestone with feedstocks such as discarded clay, fly ash, and magnesium silicate. Last year we also heard about C-Crete, a Portland-cement-free type of concrete made by California-based C-Crete Technologies. At that time, a version of the material that used slag as a binder was being used to retrofit a 120-year-old Seattle building's foundation.

This July, a newer granite-binder version was poured to form a 12-cubic-yard (9.2-cubic-meter) topping slab in the upper lobby of 270 Park Avenue, a 1,388 ft (423 m)-tall skyscraper being constructed in New York City. A topping slab is a layer of concrete placed over another concrete surface to enhance its appearance and functionality.

The new granite-based C-Crete, in place in the upper lobby of 270 Park Avenue
The new granite-based C-Crete, in place in the upper lobby of 270 Park Avenue

C-Crete president Rouzbeh Savary tells us that the new cement-alternative is made by grinding up raw granite, followed by a number of proprietary steps that cause the powdered granite to be reactive with water – thus allowing it to act as a binder. No heat is required at any point in the process.

Additionally, because granite is by nature a non-carbonate rock, it neither contains nor releases any CO2. It is one of the planet's most abundant rocks, however, so availability shouldn't be an issue. Savary says that granite-based C-Crete should cost the same as traditional concrete.

The granite-based C-Crete should reportedly cost about the same as traditional Portland-cement-based concrete
The granite-based C-Crete should reportedly cost about the same as traditional Portland-cement-based concrete

As far as performance goes, the new form of C-Crete is claimed to "demonstrate pumpability, workability, setting time and surface finish akin to conventional concrete, while meeting ASTM international standards for mechanical and durability properties, a fact verified by independent third parties."

Source: C-Crete Technologies

View gallery - 3 images
6 comments
6 comments
reader
Funny how they avoid disclosing that their product is probably best described as being a one-part geopolymer.
TechGazer
It certainly sounds too good to be true, or at least without some hidden costs or problems. Basalt gets finely ground by nature all the time, yet doesn't reform into solid form, at least without high pressure, time, and maybe silicic acid. I'll wait to see whether it turns out to be an actual replacement for cement, or just another cold fusion sort of claim.
Karmudjun
Funny how they disclose this product is similar to concrete, a known high greenhouse gas emission building product utilizing portland cement. From March 2020:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0950061819329071.
While geopolymer aptly describes a concrete utilizing a binder requiring an alkali solvent to form a shape, the fact that it is a geopolymer ignores the devised chemistry that is repeatable with quite uniform characteristics. Chemistry is like that, and C-Crete is just one company attempting to disrupt the "concrete" industry to make money while reducing GHG emissions.
Iain Butcher
Um;
no-one seems to have commented that granite is full of Radon, a forever-emitting radioactive gas?
Karmudjun
Thanks Ben. Good article. More background in the process would be nice - but although I read for the incremental breakthroughs, I also like the "informed comments" that show up. TechGazer skipped over the obvious chemistry of Orthocilicic Acid causing a metamorphic fixation of the powdered granite. Iain Butcher suggests that all granite has uranium contamination - a good bit does but Radon originating from the soil beneath homes is a more common problem and a far larger public health risk than granite in buildings. I don't know why it seems none have commented on the Radon in the soil leading to lung cancer.
Karmudjun
For information on radon, here is a source I own: Hopke, P., 1996. The initial atmospheric behavior of radon decay products. Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry, 203(2), pp.353-375. Even the abstract should help those who think Radon is a perpetual airborne source of radioactivity. The primary source of radon is uranium in the soil. Radon-222 decays in about 11 years; it decays to Polonium-218, Pb-214, bismuth-214, even Pol-214. The airborne radon is diluted by the atmosphere and therefore considered a fairly innocuous gas except for uranium mines or miners. It is a component of coal miner's lung disease as well. But granite counter tops?