Environment

New type of plastic biodegrades in the ocean faster than paper

New type of plastic biodegrades in the ocean faster than paper
A prototype straw (who would ever have thought those two words would be used together?) developed by Eastman made of foam CDA for testing its biodegradability
A prototype straw (who would ever have thought those two words would be used together?) developed by Eastman made of foam CDA for testing its biodegradability
View 6 Images
The structure of foam CDA before and after the 36-week seawater test
1/6
The structure of foam CDA before and after the 36-week seawater test
Different straw materials after their 16 weeks of being continuously exposed to seawater
2/6
Different straw materials after their 16 weeks of being continuously exposed to seawater
A prototype straw (who would ever have thought those two words would be used together?) developed by Eastman made of foam CDA for testing its biodegradability
3/6
A prototype straw (who would ever have thought those two words would be used together?) developed by Eastman made of foam CDA for testing its biodegradability
Polystyrene, also known as Styrofoam, may change shape, but does not biodegrade at all after 36 weeks in seawater
4/6
Polystyrene, also known as Styrofoam, may change shape, but does not biodegrade at all after 36 weeks in seawater
This image shows how the straws were placed within the seawater tank as they were being tested by WHOI researchers
5/6
This image shows how the straws were placed within the seawater tank as they were being tested by WHOI researchers
Eastman's new foam CDA tray for packaging meat to replace typical "forever" polystyrene trays
6/6
Eastman's new foam CDA tray for packaging meat to replace typical "forever" polystyrene trays
View gallery - 6 images

Researchers have spent the last few years trying to find which type of plastic biodegrades the fastest in a marine environment as millions of tons of plastics find their way into our oceans every year. It turns out that a common bioplastic we've been using for over 100 years does, and they've learned how to accelerate that process.

Cellulose diacetate (CDA) is made from cellulose; a natural polymer found in plant cell walls, particularly in cotton or wood pulp. It's been around since the late 1800s and is used in everything from sunglasses frames to cigarette filters (its most common usage) to photography film and a million other things in our daily lives.

Researchers from Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI) have discovered that CDA is the fastest degrading type of plastic in seawater – technically classified as a bioplastic – and with the simple modification called "foaming", making the bioplastic porous, CDA degrades 15 times faster than that of solid CDA. Even faster than paper.

"We translated the foundational knowledge into the design of a new material that simultaneously meets consumer needs and degrades in the ocean faster than any other plastic material we know of, even faster than paper," said Collin Ward, a senior author of the study. "It’s a great success story in a field that often focuses on the negative aspects of plastic pollution rather than working towards solutions to the problem."

The structure of foam CDA before and after the 36-week seawater test
The structure of foam CDA before and after the 36-week seawater test

Over a 36-week-long test, CDA foam placed in continuous flowing seawater tanks lost 65-70% of its original mass. Compared to another common plastic that can be found in every ocean in the world, Styrofoam showed zero degradation in that same period.

Polystyrene, also known as Styrofoam, may change shape, but does not biodegrade at all after 36 weeks in seawater
Polystyrene, also known as Styrofoam, may change shape, but does not biodegrade at all after 36 weeks in seawater

Ward and other WHOI scientists partnered with Eastman, a bioplastic manufacturing company, who contributed to this and past studies by supplying materials, funding, and as coauthors.

The study was performed in a controlled environment in a laboratory using continually flowing seawater from Martha's Vineyard Sound near Cape Cod, Massachusetts. Researchers were able to control light, temperature, and other variables to replicate the dynamic ocean conditions.

In January of this year, the findings of a previous WHOI 16-week study were released. That study used the same seawater tank and compared eight different straws made of CDA, polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA), polylactic acid (PLA), polypropylene (PP) and paper.

Different straw materials after their 16 weeks of being continuously exposed to seawater
Different straw materials after their 16 weeks of being continuously exposed to seawater

The PLA and PP straws had no measurable sign of degradation, while the others degraded by up to 50%.

When comparing the then-prototype foam CDA straw to the solid CDA straw, researchers discovered that the foam CDA straw was degrading 190% faster than the solid CDA straw (faster than the paper straw as well, thankfully, because paper straws taste terrible), leading to the recent WHOI focused-study of foam CDA.

Already, with the success of foamed CDA, Eastman has launched a biodegradable and compostable tray to replace the common Styrofoam trays used for packaging meat – which does not biodegrade in any natural environmental conditions, land or sea.

Eastman's new foam CDA tray for packaging meat to replace typical "forever" polystyrene trays
Eastman's new foam CDA tray for packaging meat to replace typical "forever" polystyrene trays

The team's paper was published in the journal ACS Publications.

Source: WHOI

View gallery - 6 images
7 comments
7 comments
Spud Murphy
The problem is cost. If these materials cost more than the plastics they are meant to replace, companies simply won't buy them. Bean counters have a lot to answer for, actually...
Neutrino23
It would be good to know if it decomposes to the molecular level or if it just turns into a lot of nanoparticles. It sounds like this is beyond the scope of their work. I’m cautiously optimistic that this is good news.
CarolynFarstrider
There needs to be a clear statement of the end products of the degradation, and where it goes to, together with a full life cycle analysis of the materials and energy throughputs for manufacture and disposal.
Sergius
The reaction processes for the polymerization of polystyrene do not have good yields and there is always a considerable percentage of the monomer remaining, which is the most carcinogenic of all.
Therefore, the infamous Styrofoam (polystyrene foam) trays SHOULD NEVER BE IN CONTACT WITH FOOD.
Gordien
I also would like to know which plastic particles are getting into our body's cells and accumulating, and maybe ways to filter them out of our drinking water, at least. What is that joke - How do you know when you've overcooked your fish? When you smell the plastic burning!
bobmeyerweb
No word on the chemical contamination left behind? Biodegradable doesn't mean pollution free. A little skepticism, and asking important questions, is necessary here.
Flint Hills
Considering that CDA is made by treating cellulose with acetic acid, the breakdown products of this polymer should be relatively benign. They are likely to be fully consumed by bacteria and fungi.