Imaging & Diagnostics

Millions of adults could be wrongly diagnosed with high blood pressure

Millions of adults could be wrongly diagnosed with high blood pressure
The way you are positioned as you have your blood pressure taken can hugely influence the results
The way you are positioned as you have your blood pressure taken can hugely influence the results
View 1 Image
The way you are positioned as you have your blood pressure taken can hugely influence the results
1/1
The way you are positioned as you have your blood pressure taken can hugely influence the results

Leading heart health bodies have called for greater attention to be paid to how a patient has their blood pressure taken, over fears that millions of Americans may be misdiagnosed and wrongfully medicated because of inaccurate readings.

Researchers at Ohio State University, along with the American Heart Association (AHA) and American College of Cardiology, have found an alarming degree of wrongful blood pressure data due to where and how the test is taken.

An accurate reading can be obtained when a patient is seated in a chair, with their feet flat on the floor, back supported and with the arm in the blood pressure cuff placed on a surface and kept at heart level. The researchers found that other methods – such as taking it while a patient is on an examination table – can inflate numbers to give higher readings.

"That's not conducive to taking blood pressure accurately," said researcher Dr. Randy Wexler, a primary care physician at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center in Columbus.

In the study, 150 adults were split into three groups: one had their blood pressure measured on a fixed-height examination table and then in an adjustable chair with support; another had the same tests conducted but in reverse order; and the third had two readings taken while just in the chair.

Pooled data analysis found that readings taken on the exam table were considerably higher – an average of 7 mmHg for systolic blood pressure (top number) and 4.5 mmHg for diastolic blood pressure (bottom number) – than when the same test was conducted with the patient positioned properly in an adjustable chair.

Because of this, the researchers believe millions of people could be misclassified with hypertension, even though in reality their blood pressure is within a normal, healthy range.

"We were not surprised there was a difference," Wexler said. "We were surprised at how much of a difference there was."

This can result in patients being given medication to manage their blood pressure, when it’s not at all required. Apart from the side effects, medication can lead to the patient developing hypotension, when blood pressure drops too low. This can cause light-headedness, dizziness and fainting, which is particularly serious for older adults who face increased danger from falls.

“People may not need to be on as much medication, which has side effects,” said Wexler. “That's where having good and accurate blood pressure measurements becomes important."

Nearly half of US adults have high blood pressure, and hypertension is diagnosed with consistent measurements at or over 130 mmHg systolic or 80 mmHg diastolic.

The researchers also highlight the need for medical staff to have the time to properly position a patient. They found that primary care providers would require more than 26 hours per day to follow all correct preventive and chronic disease care guidelines.

"We need to make things more efficient," said Wexler. "But how do we make changes that are doable without slowing down the process of the visit?"

In the meantime, the researchers hope this study will also raise awareness among patients, to follow simple measures such as keeping feet flat on the ground, have their testing arm supported and take care not to talk during the assessment.

"We need to make sure we measure blood pressure correctly and treat it correctly," said Dr Jordana Cohen, a nephrologist at Penn Medicine in Philadelphia, who was not involved in the study. "Health systems need to prioritize this. We have to convince them it is economically smart to do so because it will lead to better outcomes."

The findings were published in the journal eClinicalMedicine.

Source: AMA

11 comments
11 comments
Rustgecko
“Pooled data analysis found that readings taken on the exam table were considerably higher – an average of 7 mmHg for systolic blood pressure (top number) and 4.5 mmHg for diastolic”.

I think it extremely unlikely that with such small differences of 7mmHg is going to lead to people being put into blood pressure meds.
Jose Gros-Aymerich
7 mm systolic pressure bias and 4.5 mm dyastolic pressure wrong reading is an huge mistake. Rustgecko seems unexperienced in the field. Blessings +
TimNZ
@Rustgecko Agree, if the small 4.5-7mmHg error makes a difference on where you are classed then you have issues. It is not lot 130 or 80 is an exact cutoff measurement
pmshah
Do look up research by an Australian reporter spreading over 5 years. Even the so called safe and healthy range was selected from a survey, sponsored by a life insurance company, of some 150,000 samples. It was the smallest grouping. The whole idea was to charge higher premium from people falling outside the range. The entire medical profession was as good as bribed into accepting this data set. That bribery practice is not carried out by the pharma industry. BTW measuring BP on the 2 arms in identical posture is very likely to yield difference of more than 7 mm of Hg column.

Same holds true for blood sugar too.
Majki
What i also found myself when I visit the doctor is that timing is wrong when taking blood pressure; It's done as soon as I come in the office, not allowing my body to calm down and go back to baseline. This is due to their procedure of having nurse/admin talking to you first, taking the measurement and preparing this info for the doc.
Only once I had my family doctor talk to me first, waited some time, took me to another room, that was darker (to provide calm i guess) and put me on automated BP measuring machine that was taking 5 measurements with 1 min breaks in between. But again, I was sitting on examination table, no back support, legs hanging down from the table without support.
Litewave
I agree with @majki that rushing you into the exam room and taking your BP before giving one time to calm down will result in increased BP levels. Plus, I am sure Big Pharma will never let this research stand because they cannot sell as much product.
LCR78
I can't think of the last time my doctor actually took my blood pressure. Its always his nurse assistant and never with the arm supported. I but most people have the same experience. Also, I have found simply taking my own blood pressure while sitting at the table gets a more consistent and always a lower result than any doctors offices. Also, simply going to the doctors office always increases my blood pressure and I am sure the same is true of almost everyone else.
JakeJake
White coat syndrome is responsible for most inaccurate readings. The best approach is to take your blood pressure at home for several weeks before a doctor's appointment and show the results to your doctor. I know people whose BP at home is normal but always elevated in the doctor's office.
Sparty
Another major cause of inaccurate BP readings is that sufficient time to sit still and relax is rarely able to be given. Ideally the patient should be sitting still for several minutes without interactions before the BP is taken. We found marked changes (lower BP) if we allowed the patient to sit still for more than 5 minutes.
PAV
I've always contended that the simple act of taking my blood pressure raises my blood pressure.
Load More