Automotive

Is the Tesla Model 3 the safest car on the road?

Is the Tesla Model 3 the safest car on the road?
According to Tesla, the numbers are in and show that people inside a Model 3 are less likely to be seriously hurt in crashes "than any other car"
According to Tesla, the numbers are in and show that people inside a Model 3 are less likely to be seriously hurt in crashes "than any other car"
View 6 Images
Hundreds of thousands of customers have pre-ordered Tesla's Model 3
1/6
Hundreds of thousands of customers have pre-ordered Tesla's Model 3
According to Tesla, the numbers are in and show that people inside a Model 3 are less likely to be seriously hurt in crashes "than any other car"
2/6
According to Tesla, the numbers are in and show that people inside a Model 3 are less likely to be seriously hurt in crashes "than any other car"
According to Tesla, the latest round of crash testing has placed its Model 3 at the very top of the tree in terms of least probability of injury to its occupants
3/6
According to Tesla, the latest round of crash testing has placed its Model 3 at the very top of the tree in terms of least probability of injury to its occupants
According to Tesla, the latest round of crash testing has placed its Model 3 at the very top of the tree in terms of least probability of injury to its occupants
4/6
According to Tesla, the latest round of crash testing has placed its Model 3 at the very top of the tree in terms of least probability of injury to its occupants
Tesla has continually struggled to meet its production targets for the Model 3
5/6
Tesla has continually struggled to meet its production targets for the Model 3
Tesla graphic highlighting the probability of injury to people inside its vehicles
6/6
Tesla graphic highlighting the probability of injury to people inside its vehicles
View gallery - 6 images

It's not without its problems, but if there is one area where Tesla does excel it is the safety testing of its vehicles. According to the electric car company, the latest round of crash testing has placed its Model 3 at the very top of the tree in terms of lowest probability of injury to its occupants, with two earlier Tesla models relegated to the remaining spots on the podium.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) had previously tested Tesla's Model S and Model X and granted them the lowest and second lowest probability of causing injuries to their passengers. A rear-wheel drive Model 3, which is based on the same architecture, was more recently given a five-star crash rating across the board last month.

But as CEO Elon Musk said at the time, these generalized ratings out of five don't tell the full story. The NHTSA also breaks down the likelihood of serious injury during frontal impacts, side on impacts and rollovers, taking into account how likely the car's design is to protect occupants from things like intruding pylons and engine blocks.

Hundreds of thousands of customers have pre-ordered Tesla's Model 3
Hundreds of thousands of customers have pre-ordered Tesla's Model 3

According to Tesla, the numbers are in and show that people inside a Model 3 are less likely to be seriously hurt in these kinds of crashes "than any other car," ending the reign of the Model S and pushing the Model X back to third place.

It's worth noting that this appears to be Tesla's interpretation of the crash test data, with nothing official available from the NHTSA at the time of writing. There is also the question of how NHTSA's safety testing might differ from other agencies around the world, and the possibility that cars only available in other regions might indeed be safer.

Semantics aside, the results do indicate the Model 3 to be the safest car in the USA, and the blog post trumpeting this point does offer an interesting breakdown of the safety advantages of electric car design.

With no engine to speak of and a motor fixed to the rear axle, the front end of the Model 3 serves as a crumple zone designed to absorb impact energy and control the deceleration of the people inside. This is helped further by airbags that dynamically adjust their pressure in response to the crash and a collapsible steering column.

According to Tesla, the latest round of crash testing has placed its Model 3 at the very top of the tree in terms of least probability of injury to its occupants
According to Tesla, the latest round of crash testing has placed its Model 3 at the very top of the tree in terms of least probability of injury to its occupants

Tesla says the performance when it comes to pole impacts, where a tall and thin structure barrels in between the car's main crash rails, is due to carefully placed lateral and diagonal beam structures. Its high resistance to rollover crashes, meanwhile, is attributed to the car's "extremely low" polar moment of inertia. This means its heaviest components, including its battery pack and motor, are placed as close as possible to the car's center of gravity.

Tesla has continually struggled to meet its production targets for the Model 3, though things do appear to be heading in a positive direction. The company has posted record losses this year, most recently a US$718 million net loss in Q2, but also upped production of the Model 3 to 7,000 a week by the end of June.

Hundreds of thousands of customers have pre-ordered the mass-market electric sedan so far.

Source: Tesla

View gallery - 6 images
1 comment
1 comment
guzmanchinky
This is amazing! But safest in the world? Safer than a giant Mercedes S class? Or the giant GLS or Suburban or Expedition??? From a rollover perspective I would certainly understand it is the champion, but from a mass vs mass perspective? I'm curious...