Mobile Technology

What’s best for campus computing? Comparing laptops, tablets and 2-in-1s

What’s best for campus computi...
From L to R: Lenova Yoga 900S, Google Pixel C, MacBook Pro with retina display, iPad Pro
From L to R: Lenova Yoga 900S, Google Pixel C, MacBook Pro with retina display, iPad Pro
View 5 Images
Microsoft Surface Book, shown with screen flipped around in stand mode. 
1/5
Microsoft Surface Book, shown with screen flipped around in stand mode. 
The iPad Pro has millennial appeal, but is it powerful enough to justify a student purchase?
2/5
The iPad Pro has millennial appeal, but is it powerful enough to justify a student purchase?
From L to R: Lenova Yoga 900S, Google Pixel C, MacBook Pro with retina display, iPad Pro
3/5
From L to R: Lenova Yoga 900S, Google Pixel C, MacBook Pro with retina display, iPad Pro
Apple's 13-inch MacBook Pro with Retina Display
4/5
Apple's 13-inch MacBook Pro with Retina Display
Apple's 9.7-inch iPad Pro, which has terrific portability and simplicity, but falls short in other areas
5/5
Apple's 9.7-inch iPad Pro, which has terrific portability and simplicity, but falls short in other areas

Between homework, official university communication (which often takes place over email) and even entirely online courses, some degree of personal computing is necessary to get through campus life. So what's best for a college student: a laptop, a tablet, a 2-in-1 or some other magical blend of devices?

Laptops: the old standby

Laptops edge out tablets in some obvious ways: For starters, their often-larger screens and built-in keyboards make long-term typing, research and Netflix binges a little more comfortable. They also have bigger hard drives and are better equipped for expansion. Exact configurations vary, but laptops usually have plenty of ports and jacks for USB drives, accessories and chargers (though Apple's 12-inch MacBook is a notable exception). Most tablets don't even have options for wired external storage.

Also, laptops tend to be more durable than tablets. It's still advisable to use a case or padded bag, but since they fold shut, the screen is protected when not in use. The bigger size also makes it less likely they'll be lost or stolen.

Apple's 13-inch MacBook Pro with Retina Display
Apple's 13-inch MacBook Pro with Retina Display

There are plenty of worthy options for student laptops. One caveat: When it comes to operating system, the decision should not come down to preference alone. Some campuses and majors overwhelmingly support Windows over Mac, or vice versa.

For example, business majors might find a PC more in line with their needs (a free subscription to Microsoft Office is often included) while graphic designers still adhere to Mac as the industry standard. So avoid any unpleasant surprises, and check with the school or department head first.

Our top choice for a macOS student laptop is the 13-inch Retina MacBook Pro. It has ample ports, a crisp display and is big and powerful enough to cover pretty much any college computing need without being overkill.

Replacing a laptop with a tablet

So if laptops are overwhelmingly the choice of college students due to their portability and adaptability, are tablets even better? After all, they're small, light and easy to pack away in a backpack or purse. They make it possible to take notes even in the most cramped of lecture halls – or go ahead and record the lecture, since many tablets have great video recording. Tablets have longer battery life than laptops, and most include cellular data options, so you can get work done even without WiFi.

Tablets also make excellent e-readers. Many textbooks are now available in e-reader format at dramatically lower prices than print versions, and sometimes even for free. Depending on the school, major, and texts required, a tablet could help keep a student's backpack empty and their wallet full (or maybe just less empty).

But this mobility comes at the expense of performance. What if you want to watch a video, message a classmate, and type into a word processor at the same time? What if you need to print out notes from a tablet?

The iPad Pro has millennial appeal, but is it powerful enough to justify a student purchase?
The iPad Pro has millennial appeal, but is it powerful enough to justify a student purchase?

When it comes to multi-tasking, tablets aren't the best bet. Apple's iOS 9 includes a Split View option that works on certain new iPads, but it still limits use to two apps at a time, with no windowed or layered views. Similarly, Android Nougat promises split-screen app viewing and picture-in-picture capability, but these features are still limited and have yet to roll out to anything but the Nexus 9 and Pixel C. And even with apps sharing the screen, moving content from one app to another is often difficult or impossible.

Printing from a tablet requires beyond-basic OS skills and either an AirPrint-enabled printer (for iOS devices) or Google Cloud Print (for Android). Most tablet applications don't have a designated "print" button, so there are some hoops to jump through to access device printing options. Then, you'll need a printer configured to receive files over WiFi. An organized student with a flawlessly operating printer may never have a problem with this, but that's like finding a unicorn. It's easy to see how trying to print a last-minute assignment from a tablet could turn into a massive headache.

Some tablet shortcomings are easily mitigated with peripherals. For example, there are QWERTY keyboard accessories that can substitute for the touch screen keyboard (and following Apple's iPad Pro series, tablet keyboards are becoming more of a thing). Essential student software is available for Android and iOS tablets nowadays, like Microsoft Office, flash card, studying and note taking apps.

Apple's 9.7-inch iPad Pro, which has terrific portability and simplicity, but falls short in other areas
Apple's 9.7-inch iPad Pro, which has terrific portability and simplicity, but falls short in other areas

But other problems are not so easily swept aside. Tablets aren't always particularly ergonomic for long-term typing – even with a keyboard, count on being hunched over and peering into a small-ish screen. File storage and transfer is largely (if not entirely) cloud-reliant. And although mobile apps have come a long way, they often still don't have the power and versatility of their full-size counterparts (for example, see Photoshop Lightroom for iOS and Android vs. Photoshop CC or Lightroom CC for desktop).

That being said, a tablet could be a handy sidekick for a student that prioritizes portability over power. A 9.7-inch iPad Pro used in conjunction with the "Pencil" stylus (sold separately) could be a good fit.

One huge thing to keep in mind, though: Many campus systems for online classes still require Flash, which is a no-go on mobile OS-running tablets like the iPad, Galaxy Tabs and Pixel C.

2-in-1s: best of both worlds

2-in-1 devices combine the laptop appearance and (usually) software with tablet perks like touch screens and the ability to operate keyboard-free. Since we included Android and iOS devices like the iPad Pro and Pixel C in the tablet group, we're limiting the 2-in-1 group to Windows 10-running transformers.

Microsoft Surface Book, shown with screen flipped around in stand mode. 
Microsoft Surface Book, shown with screen flipped around in stand mode. 

These devices with Microsoft's desktop operating system and full computing power are the better option for students that want one machine for handling everything from heavy-duty homework to e-reading. Microsoft Surface Book is perhaps the most powerful option in this category; the Surface Pro 4 and Lenovo Yoga 900S make for more streamlined takes. Any should work for a wide range of academic uses, and the higher-end (but expensive) models of the Surface Book, which rock a Core i7 chip and dedicated Nvidia GPU, could even potentially work for design majors.

Other ways to bridge the device gaps

If the preceding options don't squarely fit your needs, it's easy to bridge the gaps through mixing and matching of devices.

A smartphone is a great tool for accomplishing this. A phone works just as well as a tablet for many student uses: recording video, accessing the cloud, sending late-night emails pleading for an extension. Upgrading to a larger-screened phablet and using it in conjunction with a laptop would be ample technology coverage for almost anyone.

E-readers are a smart choice too. If the books in your program are being offered electronically, then the money saved on textbooks will more than make up the cost of the device. An entry-level Kindle starts at US $79.99.

Overall, we are tempted to suggest a capable 2-in-1 like the Microsoft Surface Book as a versatile option for campus life, but it's still hard to beat the MacBook Pro with Retina Display or (if you can live with last-gen screen resolution) MacBook Air. For a deeper look, check out our fairly comprehensive comparison between leading 2-in-1 devices.

3 comments
Rann Xeroxx
Not sure why you break out Windows tablets like the SP4 or the Samsung Pro from others like the iPad Pro? The SP does not even come with a keyboard, its a tablet that has an option for one (we use them as meeting room controllers and don't buy keyboards with them). And why not put the iPad Pro in the 2:1 for that matter? Like the SP4, it does not come with a keyboard but has a specially designed mag port to support one.
MaryAnnConfar
I'm a librarian at a community college where many if not most of the students don't have much money. Any Apple device is beyond their budget. My campus started a pilot project loaning laptops - with only 20 - and were 'sold out' in minutes. I've recommended they invest in tablets with keyboards like the one I got for $79 at Walmart last Christmas - the RCA Viking Pro 10.1" 2-in-1 Tablet 32GB Quad Core. Our campus uses Canvas (an online learning management system) for online and Hybrid classes and we provide access to a 'cloud' where students can use the latest Apps (Office 2016) and store their documents in a cloud folder specific to their student account - so storage space is not a problem. An inexpensive tablet like the one I use... with wireless internet access (we have free wireless around campus) would provide students with all the computing power they need for most college paper writing, online class participation and note-taking. I learned from one of our IT guys that the college spent about $1,400 on each of the 20 laptops they are currently loaning. With my idea they could provide 20 x 14 as many computers to our needy students.
Jeff Goldstein
As the parent of a grad school student over the last 6 years I have seen what a lot of current students have. All have smartphones and I believe that all have laptops with many of the newer ones 2 in ones like the Lenovo Ideapad Flex or Yoga. Many also have tablets in addition to their phones and laptops. For almost anyone I just can't see the tablet as a substitute for a laptop. A high end gaming laptop has the performance and graphics capabilities to run engineering programs better than the desktops in the engineering labs. A lightweight, smaller 2 in 1 combined with a smartphone can do everything a tablet can do but possibly not as conveniently for reading ebooks for example. The article doesn't talk about total cost and doesn't take into account that the entering freshman may already own some devices. The new student probably has a $600 smartphone already for example. Assuming they are starting fresh I think it makes sense to by a moderately priced laptop like the Lenovo Flex 4 and a moderately priced tablet like the Samsung Tab4. If one breaks or is lost the other can substitute for the other and together they cost less than an expensive Surface, iPad Pro or Macbook.