Energy

Thermal power cell harvests electricity from heat at record efficiency

View 2 Images
A small lab test of the new thermophotovoltaic cell
Brenda Ahearn, Michigan Engineering
A small lab test of the new thermophotovoltaic cell
Brenda Ahearn, Michigan Engineering
A diagram of the new thermophotovoltaic cell, along with a chart of its performance against others of its type
Roy-Layinde et al.

A new heat-to-energy converter has reached a record efficiency of 44% – the average steam turbine manages about 35%, for comparison. This thermophotovoltaic cell is a major step on the way to sustainable, grid-scale renewable energy storage.

With renewable energy prices dropping fast, the barrier now is their intermittency – the first point any renewable energy skeptic will throw at you is “but what happens at night or when the wind isn’t blowing?” A little thing called “batteries” can help there, and there’s no shortage of grid-scale storage systems that can save energy for (literally) rainy days. That includes scaling up classics like lithium-ion batteries, or more experimental designs like iron-air, water-in-salt, flow batteries, or a variety of gravity-based systems.

One of the most promising avenues is storing energy as heat. The medium itself can be broad – sand, molten salt, volcanic ash, carbon blocks, clay bricks and many others are in the works – but unfortunately getting the energy back out of heat and turning it into electricity can be the tricky part.

That’s where the new system comes in. Developed by researchers at the University of Michigan, this device works on the principle of thermophotovoltaics. It’s similar to solar cells, which are photovoltaic, generating electricity (volts) from light (photons). Thermophotovoltaics obviously add heat (thermo) to the mix. In practice, that means they absorb photons from the infrared part of the spectrum, rather than the higher-energy, visible-light photons that solar cells capture.

The new thermophotovoltaic cell was tested with silicon carbide as the heat-storage material, although it could be swapped out for whatever else works. This is surrounded by a semiconductor material made of indium, gallium and arsenic, carefully designed to capture the broadest range of photons, and specifically those produced by the heated material.

When the team heated the material to 1,435 °C (2,615 °F), it starts radiating thermal photons at a range of energy levels, with 20 to 30% of them able to be captured by the semiconductor. To make use of some of those with higher or lower energies, the cell contains a thin layer of air after the semiconductor, followed by a gold reflector layer. This bounces some photons back to the semiconductor to be converted into electricity, while others bounce back to the heat storage material, giving them another chance of being emitted as the right kind of photon.

A diagram of the new thermophotovoltaic cell, along with a chart of its performance against others of its type
Roy-Layinde et al.

This design results in a total power conversion efficiency of 44%. That makes it much more efficient than others that operate at the same temperature, which top out at 37%. Other designs have surpassed 40% before, but they work at much higher temperatures that can be less feasible in many situations.

The idea is that the storage material can be heated up using electricity generated by a wind or solar farm, or directly absorbing excess heat from industrial processes or solar thermal energy systems. It might only have half the efficiency of lithium-ion batteries, but being much safer and cheaper to make and run means it’s still cost-effective to throw out half your electricity anyway, especially since it’s no longer a finite resource. The team says that there’s still some room to grow, too.

“We’re not yet at the efficiency limit of this technology,” said Stephen Forrest, contributing author of the study. “I am confident that we will get higher than 44% and be pushing 50% in the not-too-distant future.”

The research was published in the journal Joule.

Source: University of Michigan

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Flipboard
  • LinkedIn
7 comments
Username
This will be good for Voyager 3 !
paul314
comparing this tech to a single-stage steam turbine is unfair, because those turbines are limited to a high-end temperature under 700c. Gas turbines, which can operate at temperatures similar to these experiments, have efficiencies over 40%, and combined-cycle systems (where the exhaust heat of the high-temperature turbines is used to a lower-temperature turbine) can have efficiencies exceeding 60%. So whether this cell is a big deal depends on the source of the heat that it's harvesting, and also on where its waste heat goes.
guzmanchinky
80% of gasoline is wasted as heat. Wonder if this could help?
jerryd
2600F is rather high for storing heat and you could get triple cogen from that high likely at 70% efficiency, beating the pants off this rather expensive thermal cell.
Most everything melts lower than that temp and insulation losses will be high.
Bob Stuart
Where does the other 56% go? Usually, wasted energy winds up as heat.
Gregg Eshelman
A heat to electricity generating unit replacing part of an engine's exhaust pipe could reduce the size of the alternator required, or eliminate it. Converting waste heat from the exhaust to electricity would be "free", no drag on the engine as there is with an alternator.
Jinpa
Over 40% of the energy in gasoline is wasted in cars, by friction and heat. Carnot worked that out long before there were cars. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_cycle
This article is misleading in comparing the high-temperature Michigan work to ambient-temperature solar panel cells.