Who could possibly compare to Superman, the Man of Steel? Definitely not a man of plastic! Right? Wrong. Researchers at the University of Sharjah, UAE, have discovered that plastics, in certain shapes, may perform as well as steel bars as reinforcement materials in concrete.
In a study that was as much about the shape of the material as the material itself, the researchers 3D-printed and tested various material configurations, finding that certain shapes outperformed others by up to 500% in specific tests.
Concrete, which primarily comprises cement, water, and aggregates, is the most used construction material in the world. This composite is often upgraded with steel reinforcement to a stronger version called reinforced concrete.
Over the past century, steel has proven to be a highly effective concrete reinforcement material, so much so that more than 20% of the almost 2 billion tonnes of global steel produced annually is used to reinforce concrete.
Now, despite its celebrity and effectiveness, steel presents numerous drawbacks. For starters, it is heavy. A cubic yard of reinforced concrete typically contains 150 to 250 pounds (68 to 113 kg) of steel; figures can rise to well over 300 lb (136 kg) in heavily reinforced applications. Steel is also susceptible to corrosion, which can compromise structural integrity over time.
Finally, steel has an enormous environmental footprint. Its production, from mining and refining to shaping, transporting, and assembling, requires enormous amounts of energy. This energy-intensive process contributes significantly to greenhouse gas emissions, making steel one of the most carbon-intensive materials in construction.
Given all these downsides, researchers have been developing alternative reinforcement materials, such as glass fiber-reinforced polymers and carbon fiber-reinforced polymers, for years.
The University of Sharjah researchers turned to a far more accessible but less likely material: polylactic acid (PLA), a biodegradable thermoplastic. In the study, the researchers focused not only on the material but also on the shape of the reinforcements.
Cylindrical bars have been the go-to shape for both steel and its alternatives. But what do other shapes have to offer? This is one of the major questions the researchers set out to answer.
Using 3D printing, they produced flat, platelike structures and wavy, serrated, and triangular patterns designed to grip the concrete more effectively and improve stress transfer. They then tested these shapes against traditionally straight PLA bars. The findings were outstanding, with the unconventional shapes significantly outperforming more traditional bars.
“Plates outperform bars. Beams reinforced with PLA plates achieved up to twice the peak load capacity and absorbed up to five times more energy (toughness) than those using simple PLA bars. The increased surface area of the plates allowed for a much stronger bond with the concrete,” explained Dr. Muhammad Junaid, head of the research.
The study published in the journal Construction and Building Materials also revealed that the triangular and wavy forms significantly enhanced the beam's ability to handle post-cracking stress. “These serrated shapes acted like teeth, locking into the concrete to prevent slipping,” Dr. Junaid explained.
In PLA vs PLA tests, the plates and the wavy reinforcements outperformed their bar counterparts. But how did they hold up against steel? Quite well. The researchers found that a combination of shapes, forming triangular wavy plates, was most effective. Concrete reinforced with these plates matched its steel-reinforced counterpart in ductility. The triangular wavy PLA plates also achieved up to 80% of the bending strength of a traditional steel-reinforced beam. Not bad at all, considering the additional benefits.
Steel has been used in construction concrete for quite some time now, and we probably won't see it vanish any time soon. However, the study demonstrated yet another potentially viable alternative for certain applications. PLA is biodegradable, corrosion-resistant, much lighter than steel, and generally much more sustainable. There's also the customization on demand angle using 3D printing. It is important to note, however, that the study was done using small-scale prototypes.
Source: University of Sharjah via AlphaGalileo
